{ "schema": 1, "revision": "ST096-government-history-v10", "checked_date": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "baseline_revision": "ST096-local-v6", "baseline_hashes": { "public/admin.html": "327a8c54b11094f4795c856cc7829d4ca7e0c323dcb4774c3e13ff850771c1bd", "public/admin.js": "3851bf3041c44e5febac12d83691371b2bf948e341c65e3575a8a1ea48f8d5a9", "public/app.js": "0b5a48d116f771ccbeccdeca08bfecceb85bbb5eace3cec0c00c5cb49946c336", "public/ballot.json": "3a1222c8f7a734035519c46703e14e8f723c8ff7fdccde6372843ff040f9b996", "public/bank-client.js": "388f3a8586de7f365f185cee0ba19a89419ab69e96850cdb1fa7517597033a4a", "public/candidates.js": "5cf296d84725c06b82b6707c5fe1d7ac2730a6085b671799bcb2526d28fc867f", "public/context.json": "4baf4c2d9996498f5fe5de7b9f4b32cf8b8009cb279265c73e8c8537765c6e26", "public/decision-ui.js": "4df755514d3a64d44b943d4b24fd9b02cfe3c84dff6c6c1d07b60625aeadf9c0", "public/government.html": "3b3f99057c54d151b0dbd8e17ddbee9a040a9bb6525a9c790f4ae15d8d98b2f8", "public/government.js": "06347b1b20f196a9e4ecd970740bcc64edebf079e0c86664fe454dce2553a729", "public/images/contest-tennessee-governor-candidate-1.jpg": "1723cfec6048c8b0370e3b3ee5df852e0391bf18f9d82d6fb47aeeb1e59f8a86", "public/images/contest-tennessee-governor-candidate-10.jpg": "bb5153724fa6a3ff1a86487be204da48c0373824525d9154a818630e14cd05fd", "public/images/contest-tennessee-governor-candidate-11.jpg": "3fd567be53f3e6485167fdc293fd12d5fde3da7add323fc19bcf291d381a763e", "public/images/contest-tennessee-governor-candidate-12.png": "31d842760e55c394e809479c7c85e374fb96eef95eb038c60ccb06055e51874d", "public/images/contest-tennessee-governor-candidate-15.jpg": "c69bc1bddf9d44ef6c62ea6c05f9971093cb94dde31c46df9d442e6dae4014b4", "public/images/contest-tennessee-governor-candidate-2.jpg": "94500aa8bc27d41995dc96bd26caf6094f430f1d66c06fd903235bcad16a62b1", "public/images/contest-tennessee-governor-candidate-6.jpg": "c0fa89b0db4bceb8dce842e3d97e31d6673b67eff4e50530efbfc2143112c930", "public/images/contest-tennessee-governor-candidate-7.jpg": "93cb259db19c36c8cebe3957ab72f16e783dfe1a67f5a9d608676fcda18d13eb", "public/images/contest-tennessee-tennessee-house-of-representatives-district-91-candidate-1.png": "69b79d21a16b9549369469e571cfda95c04a85df4ee35119876813e862305850", "public/images/contest-tennessee-tennessee-senate-district-29-candidate-1.png": "d8e1b5349f9a49ac4cd71f3122a6ef165bee720e8c0870eb202d408298cd5547", "public/images/contest-tennessee-united-states-senate-candidate-1.jpg": "3c876ccfd3fa7272abc611b37fddcb08826f1e9e40cdc7d92f62ce7d1a14e17a", "public/images/contest-tennessee-united-states-senate-candidate-10.jpg": "15e17e723069b849a5efb99de35de664450ee57fcac7ece81e4610373ce3dfe8", "public/images/contest-tennessee-united-states-senate-candidate-4.jpg": "63f3399f1c9340724c9189e71a180fad19bc71527319082fe9ecf622fb687052", "public/images/contest-tennessee-united-states-senate-candidate-6.jpg": "2179e90d96a7e80861a2a0360edf7521f1871310c213345aa99920e058ecc7c0", "public/images/contest-tennessee-united-states-senate-candidate-8.webp": "30d19faff8d1a1e386a216c6eb3131414ea82e867a3c39482deb84d8327bad8b", "public/images/contest-tennessee-united-states-senate-candidate-9.jpg": "1aecd084496e6855bd61fff6f0ba17abfbba7949e94d79841b5e58debb69606b", "public/index.html": "773439aaa870ebe88d269b0522cfd89de119c1a913253c67693f38d08d40a089", "public/plan.js": "ccbacb1bc0ed52418d8983f88d2a0f24d0cbcd3bd23b38efecee36bbd8f5f54b", "public/question-bank.html": "0432ae4b31385b9edfba977ce70b70c76bdcfd827b642e686b1823c32bca84c6", "public/question-bank.js": "cd757456746931b0e215c3f1ddea81448fcdd562237802c362318c98ed49f637", "public/question-steward.html": "73164150577d9e71a39251872b635dee2241876eb70b2b32e0cb29b8aaac91c9", "public/question-steward.js": "47b4a043fe73e37d5e189f2bca42a887be52d07e560e843237aa067b99fc66b1", "public/release.json": "d60b7af1f4fa9ba71f9e2e77d5e868f4e455c6187c49bbcc41f2d01dd408be79", "public/responsibilities.css": "ce14663d17981383d8aded6c0f74c9d926be969343a5982e71b753cc1a0e8701", "public/responsibilities.json": "4f753c34396d99a94bcc2004386bb6b98b046101dd50934fa33685d5a3f88fc3", "public/responsibility-ui.js": "cfdf8fad6aabaee4bee13b133c998c74a995aa03142a98abb497ef6888be9bf8", "public/review-state.js": "cf96dd7ba65473ab65e18b914cacb1eaf2fcb410d42c0f1c8a099e4fa76b2b2c", "public/role-graph.css": "d69835d94dd899f6615e806d3f192c6aa556d553d34380dfc8d17a4a20a436ac", "public/role-graph.js": "c5a36723e0dbf48c4520fa80fef1737488356ab7f80e9762a669bad79041ed49", "public/sourcebook.html": "fe5fdd72aa734b43b24a8cb070c1a5bc7516331c0397b5a0db8ab638e8437f49", "public/sourcebook.js": "b2fcf8915a4ace76d91c960e720e3744054fe155ad56eaf3bdffecc98028408d", "public/sources.json": "84357ea9d19360f5e1de7032a53256e102f8c20ab5066ff5c9784988fa92bf3a", "public/style.css": "bf68c65b98b0280efb6d6ad116c20e517e7baf283fa6b467259e0a4be5107a93", "public/topic-profile.js": "25348795f7f3fb84ae984293c9da2c954d15fc44076f7c1a4eaefb624260def6", "public/topics.json": "ab581b208761f1c1df9387ae4e50a46d79da2600727a1c66916fc56dde858878" }, "sources": [ { "id": "obs-CITY01-be604a8afc83", "source_id": "CITY01", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/gov-guide/", "title": "Gov Guide - City of Memphis", "locator": "City Government and Budget Process headings; retrieved lines 364-400", "statement": "Official explanatory guide, not the operative charter; do not rely on incidental election/population fields without dedicated checks.", "qualification": "Official explanatory guide, not the operative charter; do not rely on incidental election/population fields without dedicated checks.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "577c0b0c49febe92f53fc2803fcc0a76ccc5e4ec6d6fc335aeb41ec05c3c18a9", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY02-1eab8766c07b", "source_id": "CITY02", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/executive/", "title": "Executive Division - City of Memphis", "locator": "Executive Division description", "statement": "Administrative description does not substitute for specific powers, mandatory duties or delegation instruments.", "qualification": "Administrative description does not substitute for specific powers, mandatory duties or delegation instruments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "582817bbdf81e3a044daf73ff665f1863fd718baf190fb1b6d8f73d710250acc", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY03-385688d37291", "source_id": "CITY03", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/Council-Rules-of-Procedure-01272026.pdf", "title": "Memphis City Council Rules of Procedure including January 27, 2026 amendments", "locator": "Rules 1-6, 23, 26, 46-48, 53; PDF pages 5-6, 9-10, 19 and 21; printed pages 1-2, 5-6, 15-16, 17-18", "statement": "Underlying charter section number for Rule 48 not supplied in the PDF; later unincorporated amendments were not exhaustively searched.", "qualification": "Underlying charter section number for Rule 48 not supplied in the PDF; later unincorporated amendments were not exhaustively searched.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "144b49d18d4ee8f6ef2e6ff6fac6ab9a8a2c2eec98c2382b1a736c37059f0eaa", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY05-30478fba296e", "source_id": "CITY05", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/public-works/", "title": "Public Works - City of Memphis", "locator": "Main Public Works description, retrieved line 244", "statement": "Does not identify ownership or contractual maintainer of a specific road segment.", "qualification": "Does not identify ownership or contractual maintainer of a specific road segment.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "4a0393b7e2793a2dfd0a4847c1cc834857c655eece2a53cf00e0351ae2185233", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY06-7bfcab6617e4", "source_id": "CITY06", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/potholes-repairs-winter-weather/", "title": "City of Memphis Responds to Potholes Repairs Due to Winter Weather", "locator": "Body paragraphs, retrieved lines 238-243", "statement": "Undated extracted announcement references 2024 activity; goal is not established as current legally binding deadline or evidence that any particular pothole was repaired.", "qualification": "Undated extracted announcement references 2024 activity; goal is not established as current legally binding deadline or evidence that any particular pothole was repaired.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "866fc31d00fe6119b2c35df41241eac0cbdf279b5aeab5f1b3a204ef9c59fadd", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY07-702d69e6623a", "source_id": "CITY07", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/tdot/engineering-operations-division/maintenance-request.html", "title": "TDOT Maintenance Request Form", "locator": "Road responsibility note and maintenance request instructions", "statement": "A named road still needs segment-level ownership/maintenance verification; request form is not an emergency report or damages adjudication.", "qualification": "A named road still needs segment-level ownership/maintenance verification; request form is not an emergency report or damages adjudication.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "e3dbf4c2b4da3adc52ccc759894aca52f4a0d3d448afbd06c3a4627b85ab16c4", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY08-0f4039069e79", "source_id": "CITY08", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/about/governed", "title": "How MLGW is Governed", "locator": "Main governance paragraphs, retrieved lines 348 onward", "statement": "Official utility explanation pending operative charter/ordinance reconciliation; not a complete procurement exception or external regulation model.", "qualification": "Official utility explanation pending operative charter/ordinance reconciliation; not a complete procurement exception or external regulation model.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "6a4dfdcb8b0a1192fd8e6bf4d9c62df7e115bd423e595868e677506926d0e7f5", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY09-8bd07a61eea3", "source_id": "CITY09", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/news/news_2026rateadj", "title": "MLGW to Implement Final Installment of Previously Approved Rate Adjustment in January 2026", "locator": "Announcement body; January 2026 effective installment, 2023 original Council approval described", "statement": "Official retrospective claim; original final motion and individual votes not retrieved; does not prove project delivery or the cause of an outage.", "qualification": "Official retrospective claim; original final motion and individual votes not retrieved; does not prove project delivery or the cause of an outage.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "9860f92a7a00eada1828798cc1f8c694dd959df2aa8d47e53c9d10e1982ab928", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY10-3ebd1c1716d7", "source_id": "CITY10", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/about/budgetbook", "title": "MLGW Budget Book directory", "locator": "Budget introduction and links, retrieved lines 348-358", "statement": "Directory labels are not proof of complete budget adoption or amendments. Linked 2026 PDF was too large for web tool extraction; no spending/outcome claim derived from its contents.", "qualification": "Directory labels are not proof of complete budget adoption or amendments. Linked 2026 PDF was too large for web tool extraction; no spending/outcome claim derived from its contents.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "963cab8a82250cd97f0fc4b2e27b0ca77d47a2493708ba66e471b1ec7615196c", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO01-e85fa652ee1d", "source_id": "CRCO01", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://shelbycountytn.gov/DocumentCenter/View/475/Shelby-County-Charter?bidId=", "title": "Shelby County Charter downloadable compilation", "locator": "§§2.01,2.06,2.12; 3.01–3.03; 8.06,8.07,8.10", "statement": "File title identifies amendments through August 2, 2018 referendum. Later amendments/case applicability were not exhaustively verified. PDF49 pages. PDF page21 is printed17; page44 is printed41.", "qualification": "File title identifies amendments through August 2, 2018 referendum. Later amendments/case applicability were not exhaustively verified. PDF49 pages. PDF page21 is printed17; page44 is printed41.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "3ea3ed0fb304af359b17499a512e86f7fc55faa0b704b97a001e25fe4e922bc3", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO02-571b08a603a7", "source_id": "CRCO02", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/1208/Role-of-the-Commission", "title": "Role of the County Commission", "locator": "Duties; Structure; Board Responsibilities", "statement": "Useful role summary. Page still lists election term September1,2022–August31,2026 and old chair information; do not reuse as current roster.", "qualification": "Useful role summary. Page still lists election term September1,2022–August31,2026 and old chair information; do not reuse as current roster.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "c1573ae682862a2b67f4712aa13219f1881dc27ca5e974879e95f0b63dc93b26", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO03-70efe6f71cf9", "source_id": "CRCO03", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelby-sheriff.org/duties-responsibilities", "title": "Duties & Responsibilities", "locator": "Duties & Ethical Responsibilities", "statement": "Office states law enforcement in unincorporated county, jail staffing, court security and carrying out court orders. Not complete jurisdiction analysis.", "qualification": "Office states law enforcement in unincorporated county, jail staffing, court security and carrying out court orders. Not complete jurisdiction analysis.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "11ecaca801bef3cc01fd55c802c175e64f0877b86a516cf4cf3fb72932c0dcb9", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO04-873d4934b3d1", "source_id": "CRCO04", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tndagc.org/what-does-a-da-do-tn-district-attorneys-general-conference/", "title": "What Does a District Attorney Do?", "locator": "Opening role description; In the Courtroom; In the Community", "statement": "Primary institution describing its members; not a consolidated statutory text. TCA8-7-103 is a follow-up locator only.", "qualification": "Primary institution describing its members; not a consolidated statutory text. TCA8-7-103 is a follow-up locator only.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "82957f3eedcadecd1a537cc8c9900e72efa03bd10c69bc07e183b231d945550a", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO05-d75dc33f5122", "source_id": "CRCO05", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tncourts.gov/sites/default/files/docs/state_trial_courts.pdf", "title": "State Trial Courts", "locator": "Circuit Courts; Criminal Courts", "statement": "General court jurisdiction explanation; publication/version date not explicit in extracted material. No specific bail order reviewed.", "qualification": "General court jurisdiction explanation; publication/version date not explicit in extracted material. No specific bail order reviewed.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "1e5ced4146de96f85d43ef358bce70a98b1b17a94b080a443c3f8d1db3e18b97", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO06-69c4de18a1e2", "source_id": "CRCO06", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3541/SCDC-Inmate-Records", "title": "SCDC Inmate Records", "locator": "Opening description", "statement": "County corrections page describes sentenced offenders; distinguish from sheriff-operated pretrial jail. Not an inspection or performance finding.", "qualification": "County corrections page describes sentenced offenders; distinguish from sheriff-operated pretrial jail. Not an inspection or performance finding.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "7f355e6206d2a8b8910f44e53426fc431d1344af6a6fcf2eaa239c3d4b4be21c", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO07-2aa18e2f58ac", "source_id": "CRCO07", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.ctas.tennessee.edu/eli/director-schools", "title": "Director of Schools, CTAS-94", "locator": "Appointment paragraph; duties15–20; TCA49-2-301", "statement": "General Tennessee school governance. Does not establish current MSCS oversight limitations.", "qualification": "General Tennessee school governance. Does not establish current MSCS oversight limitations.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "6aa5c645ce58019fc7004117e2558cd68b482f379732d54a37b290f53a2cb0f7", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO08-d2f0619d4777", "source_id": "CRCO08", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.ctas.tennessee.edu/eli/county-school-budget", "title": "County School Budget, CTAS-95", "locator": "Budget preparation; county legislative approval; local option law/private-act caveat", "statement": "Explicitly requires local laws/private acts to be checked. General procedure cannot alone resolve Shelby-specific school budgeting.", "qualification": "Explicitly requires local laws/private acts to be checked. General procedure cannot alone resolve Shelby-specific school budgeting.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "c94282d4987f6e8fbc432c796127c8310563d688f161208005185a6e514d4383", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO09-5de7c915892e", "source_id": "CRCO09", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/governor/news/2026/5/22/gov--lee-announces-appointments-to-educational-oversight-board-for-memphis-shelby-county-schools.html", "title": "Governor announces appointments to MSCS Educational Oversight Board", "locator": "May22,2026 notice; SB714 signed; board appointment", "statement": "Confirms enacted change/appointments, not every power, later court disposition, or actual operation of every approval procedure.", "qualification": "Confirms enacted change/appointments, not every power, later court disposition, or actual operation of every approval procedure.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "63ceba75c8e4316cffcb476ebfaae3286553ba408d5c1a85860c8a0389adca28", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO10-c4d8e4cdad93", "source_id": "CRCO10", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://wapp.capitol.tn.gov/apps/BillInfo/Default?BillNumber=SB0714&GA=114", "title": "SB0714 / HB0662 legislative record", "locator": "As enacted caption; Public Chapter1057 link; May22 effective/signing and May27 chapter dates; April22,2026 conference votes", "statement": "Long Bill Summary includes old2025 amendment descriptions; do not treat those as final2026 text. Both chambers approved majority conference report April22,2026.", "qualification": "Long Bill Summary includes old2025 amendment descriptions; do not treat those as final2026 text. Both chambers approved majority conference report April22,2026.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "ab704ce09e3378e262a10b6b321a402e09195140848c14eed282a902abbde632", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO11-4b1f56c108e3", "source_id": "CRCO11", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://capitol.tn.gov/Bills/114/CCRReports/CC0008.pdf", "title": "Adopted majority conference report CC0008", "locator": "Section1 proposed TCA49-1-616(d)(6–8), pp5–8; (e)(1), pp9–12; (e)(2), pp12–15; (e)(5), pp18–24", "statement": "Downloaded26-page PDF and locally extracted with pypdf after web fetch failed. Official adopted supporting text, not independently verified final Public Chapter PDF. Court orders may constrain operation.", "qualification": "Downloaded26-page PDF and locally extracted with pypdf after web fetch failed. Official adopted supporting text, not independently verified final Public Chapter PDF. Court orders may constrain operation.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "7fe821c460a6609b80612834205ab49e8700a0734443d5ddd52c303075f4179b", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO13-a4936240dd95", "source_id": "CRCO13", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/meetings/2026/10/8/educationaloversightboard-of-memphis-shelby-county-schools.html", "title": "October8,2026 MSCS Educational Oversight Board meeting", "locator": "Agenda F/G needs assessment/transformation; H budget/contract/expenditure processes", "statement": "Scheduled agenda does not prove adopted motion/process or judicial restrictions. Page header shows inconsistent date range October8–October7; notice text specifies Thursday October8. Recording linked but not reviewed.", "qualification": "Scheduled agenda does not prove adopted motion/process or judicial restrictions. Page header shows inconsistent date range October8–October7; notice text specifies Thursday October8. Recording linked but not reviewed.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "ffdd3fff6dff29d8929431c052e2701722ccb0b7ea9ed9f040693ed38d68e691", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO14-777f01a972a9", "source_id": "CRCO14", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/116/Board-of-Equalization", "title": "County Board of Equalization", "locator": "Authority and Function; Appeals Process", "statement": "2026 header conflicts with2025 assessment-year paragraph. No appeal deadline recommendation from this pass.", "qualification": "2026 header conflicts with2025 assessment-year paragraph. No appeal deadline recommendation from this pass.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "f454da5e33a64e1766c1a8811ad45a0fd88b778f94bbb66cd73af32c19dcb8b7", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO15-54d94c51a9b3", "source_id": "CRCO15", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://shelbycountytrustee.com/213/Accounting-Reporting", "title": "Accounting & Reporting", "locator": "Requirements; Tax Collections; Allocations for Schools", "statement": "TCA8-11-104 referenced. Allocation percentages use2024 base and are not presented as current2026 measurements here.", "qualification": "TCA8-11-104 referenced. Allocation percentages use2024 base and are not presented as current2026 measurements here.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "96614aae1a4aa4aa6357dee15bd122dc81c3433dbfbbf8d588bbecb4483bbc9f", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CRCO16-5321ee5669af", "source_id": "CRCO16", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://shelbycountytrustee.com/215/Forecasting-Analysis", "title": "Forecasting & Analysis", "locator": "Forecasting Revenue; Adjustments & Analysis", "statement": "Identifies commission rate-setting and Trustee tax billing/collection; publication date not explicit.", "qualification": "Identifies commission rate-setting and Trustee tax billing/collection; publication date not explicit.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "30f1319a949de6f1cf3922df74bf401d421f102dd04ee48e44c853fb1ab75da9", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-NI01-70d53b28d9d4", "source_id": "NI01", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/environment/policy/data-centers.html", "title": "TDEC Data Centers", "locator": "Air Permitting for Data Centers; Who regulates what?; moratorium section", "statement": "Not a facility permit or proof of legal compliance; privacy authority unresolved", "qualification": "Not a facility permit or proof of legal compliance; privacy authority unresolved", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "81128a021b8cc4373f645b24769b9fd1eaca5bb69fce95770e6b955bb926efc7", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-NI03-19e51345473e", "source_id": "NI03", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/140/Land-Use-Control-Board", "title": "Land Use Control Board", "locator": "Functions & Authority", "statement": "Underlying UDC and creation instrument still needed for a production legal authority chain", "qualification": "Underlying UDC and creation instrument still needed for a production legal authority chain", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "5aae67e9732ad01110703cc3faa0cd870310419902e55f86884497d304c9b204", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-NI04-a18522d7d50f", "source_id": "NI04", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbytnhealth.com/170/Air-Pollution-Control", "title": "Air Pollution Control", "locator": "Opening responsibility paragraph; Contact Us", "statement": "No judgment on a named source's exemption, permit, appeal, or violation", "qualification": "No judgment on a named source's exemption, permit, appeal, or violation", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "9a7003e031eb632521138c3e035fc73d499b75755beb8d8c166298e35afcb220", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-NI05-4e275e57d378", "source_id": "NI05", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/environment/air/", "title": "Air Pollution Control", "locator": "Opening scope and local-program paragraphs", "statement": "Not proof TDEC is the initial permit issuer for a particular Shelby facility", "qualification": "Not proof TDEC is the initial permit issuer for a particular Shelby facility", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "e6ab2e31e25da75439ef7514540558e26e6a9dc159c8c15ac2d74a26accb9040", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-NI11-b4e85056d213", "source_id": "NI11", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbytnhealth.com/623/Air-Pollution-Control-Public-Records-Req", "title": "Air Pollution Control Public Records Requests", "locator": "Opening paragraphs and County Attorney contact", "statement": "Eligibility, exemptions and current records policy apply; no request sent", "qualification": "Eligibility, exemptions and current records policy apply; no request sent", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "b8f57058a2645424141d254c6235789ac4e31f47f668a7bc29a7f79bc90dddfc", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-NI12-e4c9fccbbc3d", "source_id": "NI12", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbytnhealth.com/310/Air-Pollution-Control-Public-Notices", "title": "Pollution Control Public Notices", "locator": "Notice links", "statement": "Linked notices not independently inspected; no live comment deadline asserted", "qualification": "Linked notices not independently inspected; no live comment deadline asserted", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "827693c901f3de54bbb32a57eddcba49647be5c083519dead14da3a8538e8f0f", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-NI13-d82d30975dd1", "source_id": "NI13", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city-council-meeting-agenda/", "title": "City Council Meeting Agenda", "locator": "Meeting Notice & Public Comment Instructions", "statement": "Public-comment rules may change; no specific current speaking limit or deadline asserted", "qualification": "Public-comment rules may change; no specific current speaking limit or deadline asserted", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "9b64dac602ffe4de62436a44a8e483d1ea83ef4eec377d4ab577cf6b32e76efe", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-RESP-TN01-625296ec9ace", "source_id": "RESP-TN01", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.capitol.tn.gov/about/", "title": "About the Tennessee Legislature", "locator": "In Detail: legislative authority, lawmaking, appropriations and bill passage", "statement": "The page also retains 113th General Assembly composition; do not reuse that roster as current. Full current constitution and applicable special powers are not established by this explanation.", "qualification": "The page also retains 113th General Assembly composition; do not reuse that roster as current. Full current constitution and applicable special powers are not established by this explanation.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "2d3aab4b2491dd080321eccc7c108e9aa945592ef898957ebd02a6c9afcb556a", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-RESP-TN02-9bf7a1a4ff6d", "source_id": "RESP-TN02", "observed_on": "2026-10-13", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.capitol.tn.gov/about/billtolaw.html", "title": "How a Bill Becomes a Law", "locator": "Introduction; Referred to Committee; Passed on Third Consideration; Signed by Governor; Incorporated into the Code", "statement": "Procedure details require applicable chamber rules. Legislative proposals and older bill summaries cannot replace the final enacted text; private acts have separate applicability.", "qualification": "Procedure details require applicable chamber rules. Legislative proposals and older bill summaries cannot replace the final enacted text; private acts have separate applicability.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "eb1d9365926115439f89e52852e9885a2c1a5e0555c536a4583bab8d61651158", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "source_id": "CITY7-COUNCIL", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city-council/", "title": "Memphis City Council directory", "locator": "Council member listing and official email list", "statement": "Names and profile links for all 13 city council members.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/aacdef30c664dc619bd65a1f26f608bd3714aa35b7fceb504cc4fb4ec65244bb.bin", "sha256": "aacdef30c664dc619bd65a1f26f608bd3714aa35b7fceb504cc4fb4ec65244bb", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.330416+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-COUNCIL.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "f33fc0346d2adc2d8281b7c1318a0c14cc975dfd165cbd11261f88fd8fe1e986", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c", "source_id": "CITY7-GUIDE", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/gov-guide/", "title": "City of Memphis Gov Guide", "locator": "Voting process Local-City; City Government", "statement": "Mayor/council four-year terms; next city election 2027.", "qualification": "Official explanation; charter amendments and precise individual service endpoints not reconciled.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/403201ddda6963f73b596ce2eabd95654fe42d68d42377c89efa0e49f4bdf353.bin", "sha256": "403201ddda6963f73b596ce2eabd95654fe42d68d42377c89efa0e49f4bdf353", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.339039+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-GUIDE.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "6cd13c24b4abf55e38ff1b9944ca75357303016f86fd1da8abdd2185dc6b26e7", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-MAYOR-9b22872db8f2", "source_id": "CITY7-MAYOR", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/government-mayor/", "title": "Meet Our Mayor — Paul Young", "locator": "Meet Our Mayor biography; office image and contact", "statement": "Current mayor; biography states January 1, 2024 oath; official portrait and mayor email.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/a04155e7458073f12df15409e1043488353247ce763f3c2efdceac194abc21e2.bin", "sha256": "a04155e7458073f12df15409e1043488353247ce763f3c2efdceac194abc21e2", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.306175+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-MAYOR.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "37aab59e838d2ded285ce21ab9884287370f557476e469d2ac9da7dc255ecbf5", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-CHAIR-755954a147fd", "source_id": "CITY7-CHAIR", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Minutes-11-04-2025.pdf", "title": "City Council minutes November 4, 2025", "locator": "PDFpp 4-5, printed 8044-8045, items 32-33", "statement": "Jana Swearengen-Washington and Chase Carlisle selected for 2026 chair/vicechair by acclamation.", "qualification": "No individual rollcall for leadership selection. Original adopted instruments control conflicts with minutes.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/c8dfb0682e81a03238057f851593cb52ffc08696fbf1182d9d195e956015958f.bin", "sha256": "c8dfb0682e81a03238057f851593cb52ffc08696fbf1182d9d195e956015958f", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.534294+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-CHAIR.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "6986aa9b9c294f3f4c4824960942067075d782428526007784a7674a2d46a421", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-JULY7-6f314e0c7959", "source_id": "CITY7-JULY7", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/final-minutes-7-7-26.pdf", "title": "City Council final minutes July 7, 2026", "locator": "Visually inspected PDFpp 1-3, printed 8272-8274; item 3 SUP 26-08", "statement": "Dated council service observation and land-use permit motion with named votes.", "qualification": "Scanned PDF downloaded and relevant pages rendered/visually inspected; nine ayes counted from names, no numeric tally printed. Original instrument controls.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/45731373753063d511488b06d5de596857febfee7412b600701b0c3581428be9.bin", "sha256": "45731373753063d511488b06d5de596857febfee7412b600701b0c3581428be9", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.262869+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-JULY7.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "3418a7f2f4f41f766eb3c1600911efbcf4911895695753174c9c896e979a2478", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-MLGWBOARD-87fca7910daf", "source_id": "CITY7-MLGWBOARD", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/about/boardofcommissioners", "title": "MLGW Board of Commissioners", "locator": "Board member bios; seven-member introductory statement", "statement": "Current seven-person roster; Pohlman chair and Person vicechair; corresponding portrait links.", "qualification": "Undated roster; generic mayor/council appointment introduction does not separately explain suburban appointment routes. Exact seat IDs and individual terms not established.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/046536487e20f295556715786cff730b9907ec8a2fe6484e7e007ad67a0b3850.bin", "sha256": "046536487e20f295556715786cff730b9907ec8a2fe6484e7e007ad67a0b3850", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.150871+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-MLGWBOARD.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "08a968a80ee048cd87b8618eb0e52299e45128f3773010c1973b15abecd2a9bd", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-MLGWCEO-b06f8a802c9e", "source_id": "CITY7-MLGWCEO", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/about/execs_presidentceo", "title": "MLGW President and CEO", "locator": "President and CEO biography; image DM 2024 a.png", "statement": "Doug McGowen currently CEO; biography says since December 2022.", "qualification": "Month precision; exact first day and current contract/term end not established.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/0da72b51b371f7db241ebdf6ee6b1ab7972452f2a6fd0546a6f4e77f39a23bca.bin", "sha256": "0da72b51b371f7db241ebdf6ee6b1ab7972452f2a6fd0546a6f4e77f39a23bca", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.341195+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-MLGWCEO.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "2148287b760610ecd7735a37842565cc35e1bb05169a3f9735d8f467b400ed25", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc", "source_id": "CITY7-MLGWGOV", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/about/governed", "title": "How MLGW is Governed", "locator": "Governance paragraph", "statement": "Operations, rate-setting, confirmation and generic three-year board-term description.", "qualification": "Still describes a five-member board, conflicting with current seven-member roster and July 2026 expansion. Cannot apply generic appointment or term descriptions to all seven seats.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/d1290e23bcc2c82b30c78b1a1740df9d5044a8c0ca90564da332035ff30eb03f.bin", "sha256": "d1290e23bcc2c82b30c78b1a1740df9d5044a8c0ca90564da332035ff30eb03f", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.427546+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-MLGWGOV.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "87c9d898f5f2f139f7d4d4c270ca8917631947a8c873bc7dc8ea909b0e2f5f0b", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION-7b9ed7219298", "source_id": "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/news/news_j26bmvotes", "title": "Former Advisory Members now have voting power", "locator": "Release dated July 15, 2026; opening and appointment paragraphs", "statement": "Butler and Lewellen changed from advisors to voting commissioners; Bartlett and Collierville appointment routes described.", "qualification": "Announcement is dated; individual appointment/confirmation instruments, precise voting commencement and term lengths remain unreviewed. Not a rollcall record.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/b2e0f4dd48ccdf770d6f843f9752deaaeccdcda8ca21379643d0d48ac29bac7d.bin", "sha256": "b2e0f4dd48ccdf770d6f843f9752deaaeccdcda8ca21379643d0d48ac29bac7d", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.470644+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "ff2da64c3e8910c4fc07ab535498241e573aab293db42905407198c1a1f0efc0", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-MLGWAPPOINT-c8afde6987ff", "source_id": "CITY7-MLGWAPPOINT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/news/Newsnov12022", "title": "Memphis City Council Approves 12 th MLGW President and CEO", "locator": "November 1, 2022 release first paragraph", "statement": "Mayor Jim Strickland selected McGowen; Council approval reported on November 1, 2022.", "qualification": "Official retrospective announcement, not original nomination letter or council rollcall; approval date differs from service start.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/74ee2c2fea0e8e79e3200a15b38a9d7074aad33080a35d3ea197f2f4717ebffc.bin", "sha256": "74ee2c2fea0e8e79e3200a15b38a9d7074aad33080a35d3ea197f2f4717ebffc", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.485650+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-MLGWAPPOINT.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "8fa39b14193fb513b8cbd15fc2a0ed8bbb333bb9a3a9b84791651179c50d3f13", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-LAWINDEX-73acc60f6ca8", "source_id": "CITY7-LAWINDEX", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://wapp.capitol.tn.gov/apps/BillInfo/Default?BillNumber=HB2592", "title": "HB 2592 / SB 2102 enacted status", "locator": "Bill History; Public Chapter 1116 link", "statement": "Enacted chapter 1116; governor signature/effective date May 22, 2026; operating-document pointer for utility board expansion.", "qualification": "Individual amendment summaries and fiscal notes are not the enacted text.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/122b1aeeae64f87550d578ae4bdbef5d55993054f1b677cf444cb9d4d102bc9b.bin", "sha256": "122b1aeeae64f87550d578ae4bdbef5d55993054f1b677cf444cb9d4d102bc9b", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.904982+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-LAWINDEX.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "5391d5b4cc8844fd17bd1e26f67721ff7560fa951beca9b1f2eda9f7c7a9f01c", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-LAWTEXT-ca03dc7314c3", "source_id": "CITY7-LAWTEXT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://publications.tnsosfiles.com/acts/114/pub/pc1116.pdf", "title": "Tennessee 2026 Public Chapter 1116", "locator": "Official legislature link; direct web and curl requests", "statement": "Pointer to enacted utility board expansion instrument.", "qualification": "Direct retrieval returned 403 in both methods. Actual adopted provisions and precise appointment/term rules not qualified in this pass.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "193ae8783d63844974df948d92466d976a6e0cb15d8ef59c85ed4d50391f9e14", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D1-de0940a719db", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-D1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/district-1/", "title": "Memphis Council — District 1 — Rhonda Logan", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/00830ae21e163124530ad9b2636b9713a54d8692ad8b960c1f577c0c0ffbf903.bin", "sha256": "00830ae21e163124530ad9b2636b9713a54d8692ad8b960c1f577c0c0ffbf903", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.651990+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-D1.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "5300fd5b28521b566171634595474f7798b4a9737ab39bacc469ffc9801a5ddb", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D2-3f7458af0452", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-D2", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/district-2/", "title": "Memphis Council — District 2 — Jerri Green", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/ace2c3e4463540f283b8688bfb4be39c4e189520e196960e093c98bcc645eac9.bin", "sha256": "ace2c3e4463540f283b8688bfb4be39c4e189520e196960e093c98bcc645eac9", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.683972+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-D2.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "71042a4e8f218de23d73c1bc1dd9448aa44899560a6393a3b844247f8b8c5db9", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D3-a05fc7db0b3c", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-D3", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/district-3/", "title": "Memphis Council — District 3 — Pearl Eva Walker", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/976599d912a254f814fd1461abef51cfee1f56cc977fbfa7083e5e003de29d42.bin", "sha256": "976599d912a254f814fd1461abef51cfee1f56cc977fbfa7083e5e003de29d42", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.705800+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-D3.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "3d11879f18a48d755ca7f344868c1ab51c941bf64ca5b5f2d54088a66d110d24", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D4-0320cc65ae56", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-D4", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/district-4/", "title": "Memphis Council — District 4 — Jana Swearengen-Washington", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/15c30d92afce9fafeefb7e8bf75c81c3a74c69e4e877e6762ab47cb34a73b625.bin", "sha256": "15c30d92afce9fafeefb7e8bf75c81c3a74c69e4e877e6762ab47cb34a73b625", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.720945+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-D4.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "d71977c8a900d8dee02f8b3e8740a7d54f1303cd07e90a6b344b0220b7e79ee6", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D5-824e7a91006c", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-D5", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/district-5/", "title": "Memphis Council — District 5 — Philip Spinosa", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/537a89d721678fae36caeec09df7cd10eddf93b33ee05389959dc1c4acddea2b.bin", "sha256": "537a89d721678fae36caeec09df7cd10eddf93b33ee05389959dc1c4acddea2b", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.764863+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-D5.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "6508555d846fc1bbbe1f9f376c2f9d2bf957b40cd7384a62f2ea26f42d8183cb", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D6-25e8a2cdcbd0", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-D6", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/district-6/", "title": "Memphis Council — District 6 — Edmund Ford, Sr.", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/fb1dc2f8947465880342d0c79ee80445b6fef905e514ed3a16adda3a199651db.bin", "sha256": "fb1dc2f8947465880342d0c79ee80445b6fef905e514ed3a16adda3a199651db", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.887593+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-D6.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "9f7cdbcc9946f5cb2da0d43c5c417c5ac8dde2fc57c98838aa065b03273e945b", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D7-afeb43c02ae2", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-D7", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/district-7/", "title": "Memphis Council — District 7 — Dr. Michalyn Easter-Thomas", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/148044f16706d76138735942954c9e3935cb3cc35c05b101f002cf5ebd0a9e41.bin", "sha256": "148044f16706d76138735942954c9e3935cb3cc35c05b101f002cf5ebd0a9e41", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.908992+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-D7.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "48d7f3052b7077eb5c06e28cf7de3f8955af1041d0cbd70ecd3db4220075672f", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P1-1deaf2cba0d6", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/super-district-8-1/", "title": "Memphis Council — Super District 8, Position 1 — JB Smiley, Jr.", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/8a732dad2524abb8baa11e59642f02b9f8f4af6ad762c4f1c6094f09ca4da8d8.bin", "sha256": "8a732dad2524abb8baa11e59642f02b9f8f4af6ad762c4f1c6094f09ca4da8d8", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.934587+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P1.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "3cd333a3c22f668494f5e80895d8c30e21370937c8db9f430805b9a23a422cda", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P2-62c8cd7911d0", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P2", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/super-district-8-2/", "title": "Memphis Council — Super District 8, Position 2 — Janika White", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/7bd15e90f6d27c646e329cd340951a1604315959e7a3b1f3e789aa211d3a7c9a.bin", "sha256": "7bd15e90f6d27c646e329cd340951a1604315959e7a3b1f3e789aa211d3a7c9a", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.948813+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P2.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "51ed1fe27962e28cc2606f0aed396f6850392475e1a53d11c94d72dd7d22fbb2", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P3-e2848a36cfb9", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P3", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/super-district-8-3/", "title": "Memphis Council — Super District 8, Position 3 — Yolanda Cooper-Sutton", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/686fc541b53cdd5e25dfcaa0892857d499be006224431cdddd6406beb8c6e48a.bin", "sha256": "686fc541b53cdd5e25dfcaa0892857d499be006224431cdddd6406beb8c6e48a", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:54.986905+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P3.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "a09b6f268ee4eaa961116adeb8c4e1401352b6ff9fd6a3f269b30301cb379552", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P1-ff1039079277", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/district-9-1/", "title": "Memphis Council — Super District 9, Position 1 — Chase Carlisle", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/d134b5f72fbe3212c279ecf446ffd10fc9313cbb107698cd7ed224915c2cd42b.bin", "sha256": "d134b5f72fbe3212c279ecf446ffd10fc9313cbb107698cd7ed224915c2cd42b", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:55.115749+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P1.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "ef48a88b3c34ee4995c9034bea0000867a0152af866f36508c78712034fd9438", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P2-3ccd8bcfbaab", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P2", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/super-district-9-2/", "title": "Memphis Council — Super District 9, Position 2 — J. Ford Canale", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/88b0738c9eea3392dd484eb08bda80e042fe00f57b05d56d5f0177b2bb0ed736.bin", "sha256": "88b0738c9eea3392dd484eb08bda80e042fe00f57b05d56d5f0177b2bb0ed736", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:55.129385+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P2.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "23623266a4a20cd5db97a8a50319f8a405d2792ef9f0ee3bb66af1439a198332", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P3-126be4ae5a44", "source_id": "CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P3", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city_council/super-district-9-3/", "title": "Memphis Council — Super District 9, Position 3 — Dr. Jeff Warren", "locator": "District heading, biography, contact and portrait image", "statement": "Current member/seat association, biographical tenure assertion and actual portrait image URL.", "qualification": "Undated publisher page observed on October 14, 2026; not a legal service-start instrument.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/2f642ef0a6aedc77d7165720e0c2048fd18efbbc5e620300e78a5a3239b47d0a.bin", "sha256": "2f642ef0a6aedc77d7165720e0c2048fd18efbbc5e620300e78a5a3239b47d0a", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:55.132353+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P3.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "73511a19f41a0af2146c6b774255eeb239f93a996b8c77e0426a8494003ca95a", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "source_id": "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/1209/Meet-Your-Shelby-County-Commissioners", "title": "Current Shelby County commissioner directory", "locator": "Commission leadership and district cards", "statement": "Names and positions for all 13 districts; leadership headings; images labelled for members.", "qualification": "Directory observation is not an oath or term endpoint. Districts 5 and 7 appear under leadership, rather than the district-card section.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/1f7e713742e8f1ae79a80a334070140e224f59bf134ac2a16d01a241d432c7b0.bin", "sha256": "1f7e713742e8f1ae79a80a334070140e224f59bf134ac2a16d01a241d432c7b0", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:26:29.386147+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/county-roster-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "2ce7b24ee2c1cbd56e201ed3e691bc5453a1bf5344b5bd5f66f86a14e4c54ab0", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-MAYOR-6b7eb2a7ed51", "source_id": "COUNTY7-MAYOR", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/213/About-the-Mayor", "title": "About Mayor Mickell M. Lowery", "locator": "Opening biography", "statement": "Current mayor; oath reported August 31, 2026; prior District 8 commission service.", "qualification": "Swearing-in date is distinguished from legal scheduled start.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/34fec6f194a60130b16a6d0f117cac03e46181546d067e88ba6886ffc1c9457d.bin", "sha256": "34fec6f194a60130b16a6d0f117cac03e46181546d067e88ba6886ffc1c9457d", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:26:31.204769+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/county-mayor-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "f28b754dee1abf3e2c9c47e9fff4d8b6c44736916aea3215d25bf9ace2a87df9", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "source_id": "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://shelbycountytn.gov/DocumentCenter/View/475/Shelby-County-Charter?bidId=", "title": "Shelby County charter PDF linked by county", "locator": "Sections 2.03(G), 2.12, 3.04, 8.03; PDF pages 14,19,23,44", "statement": "Four-year mayor and commissioner cycles; mayor September 1 start; four-year county charter officer cycle; commission approval of chief administrative officer nomination.", "qualification": "File labels amendments through August 2, 2018; subsequent amendment completeness not established. Scheduled dates do not establish individual actual service endpoints.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "210f148cd8ad5bbede8e4e5b2e1b755b8c1ecc4eeec3ca9d638d1131f71b2577", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "source_id": "COUNTY7-ROLE", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/1208/Role-of-the-Commission", "title": "Role of County Commission", "locator": "Commission terms and structure", "statement": "Thirteen single-member districts; four-year commission terms.", "qualification": "Page still calls 2022–2026 the current term and names David Bradford vice chair; treat those current-roster claims as stale against 2026 profiles and dated activity.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "ddbfa7702a227a6775af341e7ba1dd749bbfeae9dec6b030b68822aa627907eb", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac", "source_id": "COUNTY7-MAPS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/902/District-Maps", "title": "County district-map directory", "locator": "District representatives list", "statement": "Retained conflicting predecessor labels for districts 1,2,3,4,8,9,10,13.", "qualification": "Not used as the current roster; September 2026 minutes and current member profiles corroborate newer directory. Map geometry not requalified.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "579d933652bc23b708d3f16f99252ce22cd1d7a78f80faa652f828a946dbcb24", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "source_id": "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://shelby.granicus.com/MinutesViewer.php?clip_id=2972&view_id=4", "title": "County committee minutes September 23, 2026", "locator": "Present list; Law Enforcement, Corrections and Courts committee item 1; final motion", "statement": "All 13 commissioners observed participating in official capacities; Aramark food-service motion 13–0.", "qualification": "Committee passage does not establish final full commission approval, contract execution, service delivery or results. Some other amendment blocks contain contradictory generated failure labels; those excluded.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/deff782ec71ea79fdded7c773a07050bf7d688a1955e528fda1927928814f9c1.bin", "sha256": "deff782ec71ea79fdded7c773a07050bf7d688a1955e528fda1927928814f9c1", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:56.254330+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "f77478667d6b71eb65ee8e4e87dd99f6900574615ea5f54475f2443ededd3769", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D1-10a9d00cd290", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/m/directory/employee?eid=1356", "title": "Rhonda O'Dell official staff profile", "locator": "Opening paragraph", "statement": "District 1 election reported August 6, 2026.", "qualification": "Actual oath/endpoints not stated.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "294b5ed33b3eaff82eb021f8da1b98a762999cdd2874a3644d6c6fbc8b023ad5", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D2-992e7f50763e", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D2", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3463/District-2-Derek-Mills", "title": "Derek Mills official commissioner profile", "locator": "Name/title and biographical section", "statement": "Current District 2 position and committee assignments.", "qualification": "Profile may mix current position with older biography or committee assignments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "d0ed378b8e119a88a26be22bc1fd27613ec074242127d02c0b87380f62703061", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D5-d25389ecd457", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D5", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3461/ChairWoman-Shante-K-Avant", "title": "Shante K. Avant official commissioner profile", "locator": "Name/title and biographical section", "statement": "2026 reelection; second consecutive chair term; District 5.", "qualification": "Profile may mix current position with older biography or committee assignments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "92bfb730ee21d836eaf75673f16df90e97bf61e09ec6b9c65fd38694e3a25c10", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D6-9247fcc8ab4a", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D6", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3797/District-6-Charlie-Caswell-Jr", "title": "Charlie A. Caswell, Jr. official commissioner profile", "locator": "Name/title and biographical section", "statement": "District 6; biography still claims Chair Pro Tempore, conflicting with current directory.", "qualification": "Profile may mix current position with older biography or committee assignments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "40d1d1d2c228e11f186124b1057fb97aa142f9fcc2b4aef5d069dafad7b5e562", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D7-75eb6eb30ce5", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D7", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3467/Chair-Pro-Tempore-Henri-E-Brooks", "title": "Henri E. Brooks official commissioner profile", "locator": "Name/title and biographical section", "statement": "District 7; title Chair Pro Tempore; biography uses Vice Chair.", "qualification": "Profile may mix current position with older biography or committee assignments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "69a2aa6b23310f5117f3a0edc74d4a5241ee9e6618e31a1c68d42fdbeecb70af", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D8-53f375f5b45f", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D8", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3468/District-8-Will-Richardson", "title": "Will Richardson official commissioner profile", "locator": "Name/title and biographical section", "statement": "2026 election and current District 8.", "qualification": "Profile may mix current position with older biography or committee assignments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "aa1b10fa306ffdbb84f9ab09efdda7f9de413fc81637c6932d2824c85b9dea0c", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D9-b607944d97dc", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D9", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3469/District-9-Dr-Karen-Streeter", "title": "Dr. Karen Streeter official commissioner profile", "locator": "Name/title and biographical section", "statement": "2026 election and current District 9.", "qualification": "Profile may mix current position with older biography or committee assignments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "022029caaa00b904c45cd441144d1e45c0d02f267669f099dd0f459f2c6859d8", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D11-49eb980785fb", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D11", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3794/District-11-Miska-Clay-Bibbs", "title": "Miska Clay Bibbs official commissioner profile", "locator": "Name/title and biographical section", "statement": "Current District 11 position.", "qualification": "Profile may mix current position with older biography or committee assignments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "5b028e437bd88a36c44af834c476e6f48cae55b6597fe941554b06a5ebefa0f1", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D12-df09ea18fe84", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D12", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3472/District-12-Erika-Sugarmon", "title": "Dr. Erika Sugarmon official commissioner profile", "locator": "Name/title and biographical section", "statement": "Current District 12 position.", "qualification": "Profile may mix current position with older biography or committee assignments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "608244534b6fff128d65c6c3acaae25982e716370b57df3d91d7a5c4ff4e7e33", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D13-64e118c86425", "source_id": "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D13", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/3466/District-13-Amber-Huett-Garcia", "title": "Amber Huett-Garcia official commissioner profile", "locator": "Name/title and biographical section", "statement": "2026 election and current District 13.", "qualification": "Profile may mix current position with older biography or committee assignments.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "c53bed471de19b680ccfc94a3a9df8b942c8639c0d08df00baa4682f1c50ad45", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-SHERIFF-adeeb184c017", "source_id": "COUNTY7-SHERIFF", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelby-sheriff.org/", "title": "Current sheriff office homepage", "locator": "Meet the Sheriff heading and labelled photograph", "statement": "Anthony J. Buckner identified as current sheriff.", "qualification": "Linked Meet the Sheriff biography still identifies predecessor Floyd Bonner; Buckner command-staff biography still says Chief Deputy. Updated homepage role controls this bounded current display, with conflicts visible.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/7c5962f6067990d3df4654cb38e350aa20e3de2d511896789d203ca27015a2c5.bin", "sha256": "7c5962f6067990d3df4654cb38e350aa20e3de2d511896789d203ca27015a2c5", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:26:32.999092+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/sheriff-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "2a5b82b79494990e2728189b1d95880facb13876cbfacf42d119461a1df3065e", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-SHERIFF-STALE-26489edb8573", "source_id": "COUNTY7-SHERIFF-STALE", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelby-sheriff.org/meet-the-sheriff", "title": "Linked predecessor sheriff biography", "locator": "Opening biography", "statement": "Page identifies Floyd Bonner, sworn 2018 and reelected 2022.", "qualification": "Predecessor biography conflicts with current homepage; not used to assign current sheriff.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "5afabaede5ef0815638e55a5b7412b4e7181091d8086680455c8a45e9d265869", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-BUCKNER-PROFILE-fb2faba3d2f7", "source_id": "COUNTY7-BUCKNER-PROFILE", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelby-sheriff.org/le-command-staff/staff%2Bmembers/sheriff-anthony-buckner", "title": "Buckner command staff profile", "locator": "Heading Sheriff and biography Chief Deputy", "statement": "Heading names Buckner as sheriff; older text records chief deputy promotion July 25, 2023.", "qualification": "Contradictory current-role text; promotion date is not sheriff start.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "06c5f431ec42465407b4cb8b428ae2d2440b99cd5d21caef8a337483f6541994", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-DA-4973f7043fdf", "source_id": "COUNTY7-DA", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.scdag.com/meet-steve-mulroy", "title": "Meet DA Steve Mulroy", "locator": "Opening biography and portrait", "statement": "Steven J. Mulroy is district attorney; elected August 2022.", "qualification": "Election date does not establish oath, term endpoints or complete tenure history.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/0b92b983cdd10662a41e9fa182879800f6e53a7461b2570b76fa32b9cc458414.bin", "sha256": "0b92b983cdd10662a41e9fa182879800f6e53a7461b2570b76fa32b9cc458414", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:55.972246+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/COUNTY7-DA.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "0384b6eeba75d32d75893265f1199efb3fef7be24f78b9af4979a21d31aee213", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS-abf2ca8748d0", "source_id": "COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/m/newsflash/home/detail/4569", "title": "Mayor Lowery announces first five appointments", "locator": "September 15 release; updated September 18, 2026; five role headings", "statement": "Mayor announces Felecia Higgs Walker chief of staff, Maura Black Sullivan CAO, Brian Collins CFO, David C. Bradford Jr. public works director and Crystal R. Oliver HR director.", "qualification": "Announcement uses will serve; commission confirmation where required, oath, employment commencement and tenure endpoint not reviewed. Collins image alt text says Bill Collins, conflicting with Brian Collins heading.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "f4eec3bc7402a82777525495d9edb07a7b400f3d515ead9634a922cd76275256", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS-ee2dd4fa7df6", "source_id": "COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/governor/news/2026/9/15/gov--lee-announces-key-judicial-appointments.html", "title": "Governor Lee announces new Shelby criminal court judicial appointments", "locator": "September 15, 2026 announcement", "statement": "Paul Hagerman and Marques Young appointed to newly created 30th Judicial District judicial positions.", "qualification": "Source does not number divisions or establish individual oath/start/end; not a complete court roster.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/f93acff2876de7753c50804378edbd6673135629b8fd36ca2dc60cb39be70de0.bin", "sha256": "f93acff2876de7753c50804378edbd6673135629b8fd36ca2dc60cb39be70de0", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:55.753884+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "7143f9499daaadc3f4e32ce0a37e2a0ea3386e57b35919fb3976ca24d36a076e", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-CURRENT-943209db8a4a", "source_id": "COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-CURRENT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytrustee.com/m/newsflash/home/detail/415", "title": "Message from new Shelby County Trustee Joseph Lee III", "locator": "Dated September 1, 2026; opening message and portrait", "statement": "Joseph Lee III identifies himself as new Shelby County Trustee.", "qualification": "This newer office announcement conflicts with county staff directory still naming Regina Morrison Newman. Actual oath endpoints not given.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/7dd3fc59c8d6c465106c7da7e8d95de59cb068d1ae650672186a4e9e96942ba4.bin", "sha256": "7dd3fc59c8d6c465106c7da7e8d95de59cb068d1ae650672186a4e9e96942ba4", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:56.186752+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-CURRENT.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "b4d379f77717a36728dfcdca5363b8b4183c36cad543898b2fab5049ac9f29a2", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-STALE-676fec97729d", "source_id": "COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-STALE", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/Directory/Home/SingleStaff?EID=1002", "title": "County staff directory predecessor trustee", "locator": "Regina Morrison Newman title", "statement": "Directory names Regina Morrison Newman as trustee.", "qualification": "Stale against September 1, 2026 new trustee message; preserve disagreement.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "8a246b298f5c91d8e1cb2d82467ff92c390b1b696ae786e3254440df088b849d", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-ASSESSOR-73e0ad7b74ac", "source_id": "COUNTY7-ASSESSOR", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/m/directory/employee?eid=999", "title": "Current property assessor official directory entry", "locator": "Javier Bailey Sr. name, title and image", "statement": "Javier Bailey Sr. identified as Assessor of Property.", "qualification": "Undated directory observation; oath and exact term endpoints not supplied.", "capture": null, "capture_status": "link_and_reviewed_note_only", "reviewed_note_sha256": "b94bb521409b8f22ae7923947dd6778dd97c66c7592f2840451dde7f84d2977c", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-COUNTY7-DA-POLICY-aa5bf7ef82de", "source_id": "COUNTY7-DA-POLICY", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.scdag.com/news-releases/da-mulroy-issues-statement-on-program-to-tackle-racial-disparities", "title": "DA Mulroy statement on a considered racial-disparity program", "locator": "June 17, 2024 agency release", "statement": "Mulroy announced decision not to pursue a considered discretionary alternative for certain nonviolent possession-of-weapon cases.", "qualification": "Historical policy statement, not a vote or current comprehensive prosecution policy; impacts not established.", "capture": { "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/b68d0cd76d5c7d313e8a28216fbbe65cf2144798f4266532c7b9b5f6decbdef3.bin", "sha256": "b68d0cd76d5c7d313e8a28216fbbe65cf2144798f4266532c7b9b5f6decbdef3", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:56.200412+00:00", "qualification": "Retained response bytes. Capture integrity does not establish legal completeness, effective authority or semantic accuracy.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/captures/COUNTY7-DA-POLICY.raw", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "36c13632efdb46f8520ec7a2cdc1b00c538195aa40b925cbb45b9ed300042d13", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c", "source_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.scsk12.org/board/?PN=44", "title": "MSCS elected school board directory", "locator": "Board Members; district cards 1–9", "statement": "Current nine-member district directory; Porter chair, Otey vice chair.", "qualification": "Observation establishes the directory claim, not individual oath dates, term cohorts or current unconstrained powers. 2026 statutory and court-order qualifications remain unresolved.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/e6e2d99decffde9ef082d57bccb803578bee1e1f6a792810f3e9e94361edf0fa.bin", "sha256": "e6e2d99decffde9ef082d57bccb803578bee1e1f6a792810f3e9e94361edf0fa", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:26:36.076869+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/school-board-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "d5fff8f4b1b193ac48d0dff7f753b14fdccf74d7f1bb178f8184ea2d7b7d4083", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-ROOT7-SUPER-0a05ad5e3413", "source_id": "ROOT7-SUPER", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.scsk12.org/superintendent/", "title": "MSCS superintendent", "locator": "Superintendent heading and biography", "statement": "Roderick F. Richmond identified as superintendent.", "qualification": "This current page does not establish appointment resolution, contract, exact start or current court-order restrictions. An October 9 recap is not a service-start date.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/9ed812c4eecb7b97058ec386e4ec1d70b827dc0be70eac134904cd3e109ce1e7.bin", "sha256": "9ed812c4eecb7b97058ec386e4ec1d70b827dc0be70eac134904cd3e109ce1e7", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:26:36.830297+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/school-superintendent-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "2c8deac333cc21a1bbb6f16b8be2c3994bd058949b9169b09f743e7f89009e97", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0", "source_id": "ROOT7-LUCB", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.shelbycountytn.gov/140/Land-Use-Control-Board", "title": "Joint Land Use Control Board roster and appointment routes", "locator": "Members; Functions & Authority", "statement": "Ten named members, three-year term rule, five appointments each by city and county mayors with corresponding legislative confirmation.", "qualification": "Current directory does not supply individual term endpoints or original confirmations; charter/UDC amendments and joint instrument completeness remain to be qualified.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/a732eb6852f93f97e2d9c82da666a3821cdc75107603cec4828c4777ecfeec91.bin", "sha256": "a732eb6852f93f97e2d9c82da666a3821cdc75107603cec4828c4777ecfeec91", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:27.184840+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/lucb-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "33ef589f216464a5923e7ed2e60b40d0a252b55bae86af2829e14e3f6361c93a", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-7b6fca01bb92", "source_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/governor/news/2026/5/22/gov--lee-announces-appointments-to-educational-oversight-board-for-memphis-shelby-county-schools.html", "title": "Governor announces five MSCS oversight appointees", "locator": "May 22, 2026 announcement; five names", "statement": "Five gubernatorial appointments announced on May 22.", "qualification": "This is a dated announcement, not a complete nine-member roster or proof of oath/current continued service. Business titles following names are not oversight-board titles; effective legal powers and operative orders remain unresolved.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/5d8f05f6b0a0544809b44dec58b903ab48a7ae9e9515e2c6801d5ab62e4d89a3.bin", "sha256": "5d8f05f6b0a0544809b44dec58b903ab48a7ae9e9515e2c6801d5ab62e4d89a3", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:30.269915+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/school-oversight-appointment-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "aae006158dd56c8ca4bf649aa8f333969122852d6277e94a3d97cc0da9a1952d", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-ROOT7-CABINET-63e7a01bc52b", "source_id": "ROOT7-CABINET", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/governor/about-bill-lee/cabinet.html", "title": "Tennessee governor cabinet directory", "locator": "Environment and Conservation; Transportation", "statement": "David W. Salyers and Will Reid named commissioners.", "qualification": "Current directory observation does not establish exact individual appointment/service endpoints.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/7b113660735e259c2acb33d19f5ba4c677bcaa3b1c62e7e6c27f63048000bc26.bin", "sha256": "7b113660735e259c2acb33d19f5ba4c677bcaa3b1c62e7e6c27f63048000bc26", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:29.415203+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/cabinet-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "56c2fde901f7759d19a38af7a286a898bad7eda84c9174081ad0b233d71892aa", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-ROOT7-GOVERNOR-8ad51418e098", "source_id": "ROOT7-GOVERNOR", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/governor/about-bill-lee.html", "title": "Governor Bill Lee official biography", "locator": "Governor heading and opening biography", "statement": "Bill Lee current governor; biography reports becoming governor in 2019.", "qualification": "Year-level historical biography, not an individual oath record or exact current-term expiration.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/7da16cdb687ce539d3184c1d54cba79999d1697a8dabaedfd891f1a48d7a9d1e.bin", "sha256": "7da16cdb687ce539d3184c1d54cba79999d1697a8dabaedfd891f1a48d7a9d1e", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:28.893855+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/governor-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "db3d1673a5e659b403295f34e0fdf83e53aa4abc307b4a4fe16106e19f4ac967", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-ROOT7-TDOT-34a1cb3fd59a", "source_id": "ROOT7-TDOT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/tdot/about/tdot-organizational-charts/commissioner.html", "title": "TDOT commissioner Will Reid", "locator": "Commissioner heading and biography", "statement": "Will Reid identified as commissioner, appointed July 2025.", "qualification": "Current official profile, not oath or tenure-end evidence.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/adc8a89496c0fa81297e524cc7ae0e791ce6fea9dc447d589f06109c4ff823cd.bin", "sha256": "adc8a89496c0fa81297e524cc7ae0e791ce6fea9dc447d589f06109c4ff823cd", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:28.058458+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/tdot-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "050fdf8abf989babb013edb1a68683321a10aa6deefb0663e2cc7630b2371dfc", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINT-e315ec5f3750", "source_id": "ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/governor/news/2025/7/2/gov--lee-announces-key-appointment-at-tennessee-department-of-transportation.html", "title": "TDOT commissioner appointment announcement", "locator": "July 2, 2025 release opening paragraph", "statement": "Will Reid appointed commissioner effective July 10, 2025; succeeding Butch Eley.", "qualification": "July 2 announcement and July 10 stated effective appointment are separate. Oath and actual service-end not established.", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v7/evidence/0c1b42d6076d6846d1b710bb677efdd922e56ed315d2fa8f63d5e6e48663413c.bin", "sha256": "0c1b42d6076d6846d1b710bb677efdd922e56ed315d2fa8f63d5e6e48663413c", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:27:29.854016+00:00", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM snapshot, not original HTTP response bytes; dynamic resources and linked instruments not bundled.", "original_capture_path": "artifacts/government-v7/tdot-appointment-source.html", "retention": "Content-addressed evidence copy; preserve bytes and append a new hash for future versions." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "2deb23d32b993d124ee61ca323367ddc5153aaab4c7df7c6f5b00f1ce8165e21", "hash_scope": "The note hash fingerprints Memphia’s reviewed source metadata, not unseen original page bytes." }, { "id": "obs-ROUTE9-CITY311-a6ed560f7894", "source_id": "ROUTE9-CITY311", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:51:56.665229+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/call-311/", "title": "Call 311 — City of Memphis", "locator": "New request / case status link and live-agent number", "statement": "Official service handoff; no response time, remedy or individual fault inferred. Request tracking occurs on the external city site.", "qualification": "Official service handoff; no response time, remedy or individual fault inferred. Request tracking occurs on the external city site.", "capture_status": "retained_public_browser_dom", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v9/evidence/a6ed560f7894260a97c87fc7a1a39192ee5a18ac43478104592d6df422d08cc0.bin", "sha256": "a6ed560f7894260a97c87fc7a1a39192ee5a18ac43478104592d6df422d08cc0", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T06:50:19.072Z", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM text, not original HTTP response bytes. Links/forms not exercised." } }, { "id": "obs-ROUTE9-TDOT-79bf92514967", "source_id": "ROUTE9-TDOT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:51:56.665229+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/tdot/maintenance/maintenance-request.html", "title": "TDOT Maintenance Request Form", "locator": "Maintenance form introduction and state-owned road restriction", "statement": "State-owned roads only; form is not for highway emergencies. Maintainer must be confirmed; this is not a claim for damages.", "qualification": "State-owned roads only; form is not for highway emergencies. Maintainer must be confirmed; this is not a claim for damages.", "capture_status": "retained_public_browser_dom", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v9/evidence/79bf92514967b74ad277bc44b8463f16337527590875761012810672c75e6a5a.bin", "sha256": "79bf92514967b74ad277bc44b8463f16337527590875761012810672c75e6a5a", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T06:50:20.549Z", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM text, not original HTTP response bytes. Links/forms not exercised." } }, { "id": "obs-ROUTE9-MLGWCONTACT-320401e2bbc6", "source_id": "ROUTE9-MLGWCONTACT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:51:56.665229+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/contact", "title": "MLGW Contact Overview", "locator": "Residential Customer Care phone and office directory", "statement": "Customer service handoff; no account data collected here, no promised service outcome or escalation deadline inferred.", "qualification": "Customer service handoff; no account data collected here, no promised service outcome or escalation deadline inferred.", "capture_status": "retained_public_browser_dom", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v9/evidence/320401e2bbc60b735ef0b543d5e3c48e2ff672191c69f6599b930b5a889e7bbf.bin", "sha256": "320401e2bbc60b735ef0b543d5e3c48e2ff672191c69f6599b930b5a889e7bbf", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T06:50:21.578Z", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM text, not original HTTP response bytes. Links/forms not exercised." } }, { "id": "obs-ROUTE9-MLGWMINUTES-47c57a1ea281", "source_id": "ROUTE9-MLGWMINUTES", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:51:56.665229+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/about/boardminutes", "title": "MLGW Board Meeting Minutes directory", "locator": "2026 meeting links and introductory governance paragraph", "statement": "Record-discovery directory only. Introductory five-member roster conflicts with the newer seven-member roster and July transition release; do not use this page to determine membership or current selection powers. Individual linked minutes have not been reviewed in v9.", "qualification": "Record-discovery directory only. Introductory five-member roster conflicts with the newer seven-member roster and July transition release; do not use this page to determine membership or current selection powers. Individual linked minutes have not been reviewed in v9.", "capture_status": "retained_public_browser_dom", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v9/evidence/47c57a1ea281cb54e17bc3a28633205876d5a91bb15e2e4f505ac44b1a32c5e2.bin", "sha256": "47c57a1ea281cb54e17bc3a28633205876d5a91bb15e2e4f505ac44b1a32c5e2", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T06:50:22.305Z", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM text, not original HTTP response bytes. Links/forms not exercised." } }, { "id": "obs-ROUTE9-COUNCIL-fbb634742822", "source_id": "ROUTE9-COUNCIL", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:51:56.665229+00:00", "source_url": "https://memphistn.gov/city-council-meeting-agenda/", "title": "Memphis City Council Meeting Agenda directory", "locator": "Meeting notices, public comment instructions, agendas, documents and minutes", "statement": "Discovery handoff; agenda or presentation inclusion is not adoption. Check the exact meeting notice and adopted minutes for the measure and date.", "qualification": "Discovery handoff; agenda or presentation inclusion is not adoption. Check the exact meeting notice and adopted minutes for the measure and date.", "capture_status": "retained_public_browser_dom", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v9/evidence/fbb6347428226a3addd947ac746a65eb73c08de3bfe6c6f95776c8fac426356d.bin", "sha256": "fbb6347428226a3addd947ac746a65eb73c08de3bfe6c6f95776c8fac426356d", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T06:50:22.719Z", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM text, not original HTTP response bytes. Links/forms not exercised." } }, { "id": "obs-ROUTE9-MLGWRECORDS-a4e08e541a43", "source_id": "ROUTE9-MLGWRECORDS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:51:56.665229+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.mlgw.com/mlgwpublicrecords", "title": "MLGW Public Records", "locator": "Public records policy and online request form links", "statement": "Request-channel discovery only; eligibility, fees, exemptions and response rules require the linked policy. No request was submitted.", "qualification": "Request-channel discovery only; eligibility, fees, exemptions and response rules require the linked policy. No request was submitted.", "capture_status": "retained_public_browser_dom", "capture": { "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "path": "artifacts/government-v9/evidence/a4e08e541a43294cc5420aea57530916e1e520967aa34dd5719ca4de5231045f.bin", "sha256": "a4e08e541a43294cc5420aea57530916e1e520967aa34dd5719ca4de5231045f", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T06:50:22.937Z", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM text, not original HTTP response bytes. Links/forms not exercised." } }, { "id": "obs-SCHOOL10-ACT-fa72578887ac", "source_id": "SCHOOL10-ACT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://publications.tnsosfiles.com/acts/114/pub/pc1057.pdf", "title": "2026 Tennessee Public Chapter 1057 (SB0714 / HB0662)", "locator": "Final signed act; 12 PDF pages; Section 1 adds TCA49-1-616; Section4/p11 and approval/p12", "statement": "Official final chapter retrieved through ordinary public browser navigation/fetch after curl403; all12pages text-read; pages1,2,5,6,7,9,10,11,12 visually inspected. Legislative powers are subject to applicable operative court orders; this source does not establish that powers can currently be exercised.", "qualification": "Official final chapter retrieved through ordinary public browser navigation/fetch after curl403; all12pages text-read; pages1,2,5,6,7,9,10,11,12 visually inspected. Legislative powers are subject to applicable operative court orders; this source does not establish that powers can currently be exercised.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/fa72578887ac457c11c544df0675f19b4ef32aaa36e3ecdd21bb522c2a71f331.bin", "sha256": "fa72578887ac457c11c544df0675f19b4ef32aaa36e3ecdd21bb522c2a71f331", "bytes": 836360, "reading_depth": "full_document_relevant_passages", "http_status": 200, "content_type": "application/pdf", "method": "ordinary_public_browser_fetch", "pages": 12, "etag": "392c11991a99bf19e7d3b65698651042", "version_id": "iopp6iC55v6txAqLuKnVY.5SPGGgusAR", "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "qualification": "Retained bytes of the official signed 2026 final act. All12pages read; relevant authority and approval passages visually checked. Enactment does not establish unconstrained current exercise.", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:37:48Z" }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "67b5de4ca6b6901d6bcd6e36fd679fc18dc7a14ee133b3e6b8de7609855a79c5" }, { "id": "obs-SCHOOL10-BILL-116e3844db37", "source_id": "SCHOOL10-BILL", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://wapp.capitol.tn.gov/apps/BillInfo/Default?BillNumber=SB0714&GA=114", "title": "Tennessee General Assembly SB0714 legislative ledger, 114th General Assembly", "locator": "BillHistory: April 22 majorityconference adoptions; signed May 22; May 27 chapter/effective-date entries", "statement": "Official dated action ledger. Historical2025amendment summaries also appear and are not the final text; publication/entrydate differs from effective/approvaldate. No individual roll-call choices reviewed here.", "qualification": "Official dated action ledger. Historical2025amendment summaries also appear and are not the final text; publication/entrydate differs from effective/approvaldate. No individual roll-call choices reviewed here.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/116e3844db37d823d0f091366364b70817a39f8147d0135436384908c7b4218d.bin", "sha256": "116e3844db37d823d0f091366364b70817a39f8147d0135436384908c7b4218d", "bytes": 166948, "reading_depth": "full_document_relevant_passages", "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "qualification": "Retained official bill-ledger HTTP response; final passage/approval/effectiveness entries and historical-summary limits reviewed. This HTML ledger is not a substitute for the final signed text.", "retrieval_date": "2026-10-14", "timestamp_precision": "date_only" }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "ca3def7bd10b983d41b8962ba23746e49c081cc4a76fde1c5553745757cef6b6" }, { "id": "obs-COURT10-OCT5-8c5e5abcdf65", "source_id": "COURT10-OCT5", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853.79.0.pdf", "title": "Federal order, Document 79, filed October 5, 2026", "locator": "M.D. Tennessee 3:26-cv-00835; Doc 79 pp1–2 PageID3260–3261, filed October 5; docket79 describes signed October 2; operative paragraphs1–3", "statement": "Court-stamped original order retained through RECAP; live official docket completeness not certified. FiledOctober5 is the recorded filing date; docket text describes signed October 2, while thisPDF signature block has no printed date. Order does not itself dissolve July 1 status-quo restriction; laterstate depends on subsequent operative orders.", "qualification": "Court-stamped original order retained through RECAP; live official docket completeness not certified. FiledOctober5 is the recorded filing date; docket text describes signed October 2, while thisPDF signature block has no printed date. Order does not itself dissolve July 1 status-quo restriction; laterstate depends on subsequent operative orders.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/8c5e5abcdf6580e3c1f28196ed35a7a418feada16d41ef86611c971038b31232.bin", "url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853.79.0.pdf", "sha256": "8c5e5abcdf6580e3c1f28196ed35a7a418feada16d41ef86611c971038b31232", "bytes": 155099, "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "pages": 2, "http_status": 200, "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:47:41.928Z", "reviewed_on": "2026-10-14", "retrieval_owner": "root; normal public browser", "qualification": "Retained public response bytes from the stated publisher/mirror; court stamp and exact case/document identity reviewed; mirror access is not official docket completeness." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "42dbc5b1d4020d338f63c4fe2c9116a43fdc6e8f2868ac7ca9536d780978001f" }, { "id": "obs-COURT10-DECL82-fa25d797690b", "source_id": "COURT10-DECL82", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853.82.0.pdf", "title": "Billy Orgel sworn declaration, Document 82, filed October 13, 2026", "locator": "RECAP Doc 82 pp1–5 PageID3347–3351; ¶¶2–6, signed October 13 on p3; WREGcombinedpacket separately retains82-1 to82-4 attachments", "statement": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Declaration is a party/witness statement, not a judicial finding or order dissolving restrictions. Substantive first five pages are scanned: pypdf extracts only court stamps. Visual reading performed, not an absence finding based on text search. Exact member motions/votes, meeting minutes, actual staff hiring, funding receipt and outcome evidence are not established by this declaration.", "qualification": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Declaration is a party/witness statement, not a judicial finding or order dissolving restrictions. Substantive first five pages are scanned: pypdf extracts only court stamps. Visual reading performed, not an absence finding based on text search. Exact member motions/votes, meeting minutes, actual staff hiring, funding receipt and outcome evidence are not established by this declaration.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/fa25d797690be49bb5bf8c6b0c5fa1bfc5fb34b729e2c3b7cb0ac3e577f70afc.bin", "url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853.82.0.pdf", "sha256": "fa25d797690be49bb5bf8c6b0c5fa1bfc5fb34b729e2c3b7cb0ac3e577f70afc", "bytes": 1474149, "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "pages": 5, "http_status": 200, "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:47:42.188Z", "reviewed_on": "2026-10-14", "retrieval_owner": "root; normal public browser", "qualification": "Retained public response bytes from the stated publisher/mirror; court stamp and exact case/document identity reviewed; mirror access is not official docket completeness." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "e817bd266a57054d33a1ab75f85b620f27d5f42cd7b00b24d77f12333715cc78" }, { "id": "obs-COURT10-EXH-A-7d1ac25e7867", "source_id": "COURT10-EXH-A", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://wreg.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2026/10/MSCS-Oversight-Board-Chair-Says-Board-is-Ready-Now-1.pdf", "title": "October 8 meeting notice, Exhibit A / Document 82-1", "locator": "Combined PDF pp6–7; Doc 82-1 pp1–2 PageID3352–3353", "statement": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Notice is a scheduled agenda, not meeting minutes or vote evidence. Notice2-minute comment limit differs from ExhibitC§6.1 up-to3-minute rule; verify actual current dated notice. Historical meeting access codes are not presented as a current participation route.", "qualification": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Notice is a scheduled agenda, not meeting minutes or vote evidence. Notice2-minute comment limit differs from ExhibitC§6.1 up-to3-minute rule; verify actual current dated notice. Historical meeting access codes are not presented as a current participation route.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/7d1ac25e7867a4b2190b526363cd6606917c17c851793df6da0c2e5a085921dc.bin", "url": "https://wreg.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2026/10/MSCS-Oversight-Board-Chair-Says-Board-is-Ready-Now-1.pdf", "sha256": "7d1ac25e7867a4b2190b526363cd6606917c17c851793df6da0c2e5a085921dc", "bytes": 2285769, "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "pages": 26, "retrieval_owner": "root; normal public browser HTTP200", "reviewed_on": "2026-10-14", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:38:22Z", "qualification": "Retained public response bytes from the stated publisher/mirror; court stamp and exact case/document identity reviewed; mirror access is not official docket completeness." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "35c3a0a1efddea92c61b0ebf2ac2be3da2c6209de5577be4318dbee634ad0753" }, { "id": "obs-COURT10-EXH-B-7d1ac25e7867", "source_id": "COURT10-EXH-B", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://wreg.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2026/10/MSCS-Oversight-Board-Chair-Says-Board-is-Ready-Now-1.pdf", "title": "Oversight Board Executive Director job description, Exhibit B / Document 82-2", "locator": "Combined PDF pp8–10; Doc 82-2 pp1–3 PageID3354–3356", "statement": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Job description/posting approval does not establish that a person was hired, started service or received delegated power. Described guarantees/goals are role-document language, not observed delivery or independent findings of mandatory law.", "qualification": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Job description/posting approval does not establish that a person was hired, started service or received delegated power. Described guarantees/goals are role-document language, not observed delivery or independent findings of mandatory law.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/7d1ac25e7867a4b2190b526363cd6606917c17c851793df6da0c2e5a085921dc.bin", "url": "https://wreg.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2026/10/MSCS-Oversight-Board-Chair-Says-Board-is-Ready-Now-1.pdf", "sha256": "7d1ac25e7867a4b2190b526363cd6606917c17c851793df6da0c2e5a085921dc", "bytes": 2285769, "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "pages": 26, "retrieval_owner": "root; normal public browser HTTP200", "reviewed_on": "2026-10-14", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:38:22Z", "qualification": "Retained public response bytes from the stated publisher/mirror; court stamp and exact case/document identity reviewed; mirror access is not official docket completeness." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "f0157a63d180ac1f2091b3b28944c1d554fec3656f27919f7ef7e50e4641b403" }, { "id": "obs-COURT10-EXH-C-7d1ac25e7867", "source_id": "COURT10-EXH-C", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://wreg.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2026/10/MSCS-Oversight-Board-Chair-Says-Board-is-Ready-Now-1.pdf", "title": "Oversight Board rules of procedure, Exhibit C / Document 82-3", "locator": "Combined PDF pp11–18; Doc 82-3 pp1–8 PageID3357–3364; §§1.2–1.4,2.2,3.2–3.7,3.13,4.3,6.1–6.5,7.1–7.4,8.1–8.5,9.1–9.2", "statement": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Authority-commencedJuly 1 sentence in§1.2 does not establish that court restrictions had been lifted. Principal address/location/schedule remain placeholders or to-be-adopted; adoption/certification dates/signatures and templates blank. Current signed adopted version, amendment history, numerical quorum applicability and consistency with governing law/court restrictions not independently certified. Comment timing conflicts with October 8 notice; opening a source is not an official submission.", "qualification": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Authority-commencedJuly 1 sentence in§1.2 does not establish that court restrictions had been lifted. Principal address/location/schedule remain placeholders or to-be-adopted; adoption/certification dates/signatures and templates blank. Current signed adopted version, amendment history, numerical quorum applicability and consistency with governing law/court restrictions not independently certified. Comment timing conflicts with October 8 notice; opening a source is not an official submission.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/7d1ac25e7867a4b2190b526363cd6606917c17c851793df6da0c2e5a085921dc.bin", "url": "https://wreg.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2026/10/MSCS-Oversight-Board-Chair-Says-Board-is-Ready-Now-1.pdf", "sha256": "7d1ac25e7867a4b2190b526363cd6606917c17c851793df6da0c2e5a085921dc", "bytes": 2285769, "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "pages": 26, "retrieval_owner": "root; normal public browser HTTP200", "reviewed_on": "2026-10-14", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:38:22Z", "qualification": "Retained public response bytes from the stated publisher/mirror; court stamp and exact case/document identity reviewed; mirror access is not official docket completeness." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "73435179f3666ff4ba55514f2644b2f6f3f1a753fcd715592317812089f4b878" }, { "id": "obs-COURT10-EXH-D-7d1ac25e7867", "source_id": "COURT10-EXH-D", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://wreg.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2026/10/MSCS-Oversight-Board-Chair-Says-Board-is-Ready-Now-1.pdf", "title": "Contract review workflow and forms, Exhibit D / Document 82-4", "locator": "Combined PDF pp19–26; Doc 82-4 pp1–8 PageID3365–3372", "statement": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Monthly template cycle is not a legal-deadline calculation or proof any actual contract was reviewed. Illustrative C-001 tutoring-contract row is not separately qualified as an actual transaction/award. Referenced section numbers/holiday calendar/deemed-approval mechanics need reconciliation with full enacted law and complete operative procedures. Blank approval/denial/veto forms do not record an exercised decision.", "qualification": "Public WREG-hosted mirror of court-stamped filing; official live docket not independently reconciled. Mirror retrieval and stamp inspection establish document support, not completeness of current litigation history. Monthly template cycle is not a legal-deadline calculation or proof any actual contract was reviewed. Illustrative C-001 tutoring-contract row is not separately qualified as an actual transaction/award. Referenced section numbers/holiday calendar/deemed-approval mechanics need reconciliation with full enacted law and complete operative procedures. Blank approval/denial/veto forms do not record an exercised decision.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/7d1ac25e7867a4b2190b526363cd6606917c17c851793df6da0c2e5a085921dc.bin", "url": "https://wreg.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2026/10/MSCS-Oversight-Board-Chair-Says-Board-is-Ready-Now-1.pdf", "sha256": "7d1ac25e7867a4b2190b526363cd6606917c17c851793df6da0c2e5a085921dc", "bytes": 2285769, "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "pages": 26, "retrieval_owner": "root; normal public browser HTTP200", "reviewed_on": "2026-10-14", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:38:22Z", "qualification": "Retained public response bytes from the stated publisher/mirror; court stamp and exact case/document identity reviewed; mirror access is not official docket completeness." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "2722c36e477bfbd69d61625e98f1f16c3431781b469fb3027f85ccb00680de52" }, { "id": "obs-COURT10-JULY1-1f5cf7933183", "source_id": "COURT10-JULY1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853/gov.uscourts.tnmd.109853.22.0.pdf", "title": "July 1 status-quo order · Document 22", "locator": "M.D. Tennessee 3:26-cv-00835; Doc 22 pp1–2, PageID 260–261; p1 final paragraph", "statement": "Court-stamped public RECAP copy read in full; requires the parties to maintain the pre-enactment status quo pending consideration of injunctive relief. Later operative orders must be checked; this is a dated order, not an unlimited future authority claim.", "qualification": "Court-stamped public RECAP copy read in full; requires the parties to maintain the pre-enactment status quo pending consideration of injunctive relief. Later operative orders must be checked; this is a dated order, not an unlimited future authority claim.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/1f5cf79331833c18742a29a48e207cd80da85e619de027807dc6c68b752177f1.bin", "kind": "downloaded_public_response", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:47:41.409Z", "sha256": "1f5cf79331833c18742a29a48e207cd80da85e619de027807dc6c68b752177f1", "qualification": "Retained public response bytes from the stated publisher/mirror; court stamp and exact case/document identity reviewed; mirror access is not official docket completeness.", "bytes": 178322 }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "90c65fbfe7413498126678a80f0ba97fcda282bfb2061d0d67d5e73f2309b433" }, { "id": "obs-COURT10-DOCKET-8abbbb9641aa", "source_id": "COURT10-DOCKET", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/73513552/shelby-county-government-v-lee/", "title": "Public RECAP docket · Shelby County Government v. Lee", "locator": "Case3:26-cv-00835/M.D.Tenn.; header Last updated October 13,2026 3:10pm/Last known filing October 13; entries22,32,79,81,82", "statement": "Public PACER/RECAP mirror observed October 14, with last known filing October 13 and visible entries1–82. No lifting order appears in that coverage. Mirror warns it may be incomplete; this does not establish absence of a later official filing. Document32 is the dissolution motion, while Document22 is the July 1 order.", "qualification": "Public PACER/RECAP mirror observed October 14, with last known filing October 13 and visible entries1–82. No lifting order appears in that coverage. Mirror warns it may be incomplete; this does not establish absence of a later official filing. Document32 is the dissolution motion, while Document22 is the July 1 order.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/8abbbb9641aaf64e54c979f15c7903c4109af2089bb9e8aae53d403d953b0992.bin", "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "sha256": "8abbbb9641aaf64e54c979f15c7903c4109af2089bb9e8aae53d403d953b0992", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM/text and links; not original HTTP response bytes.", "bytes": 92343, "retrieval_date": "2026-10-14", "timestamp_precision": "date_only", "captured_at": "2026-10-14T13:46:01.954129+00:00", "capture_time_basis": "Local retained DOM artifact timestamp; not the docket update or event time." }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "5551822a4c9b56cdfb1f5d58616cacb7518274b164877797d5c7a411bd2bb73b" }, { "id": "obs-SCHOOL10-BOARDCHANNEL-9d71d0bfa207", "source_id": "SCHOOL10-BOARDCHANNEL", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.scsk12.org/board/?PN=45", "title": "MSCS Board Office · constituent services and records", "locator": "BoardOffice/ConstituentServices and meeting documents paragraphs", "statement": "Official office guidance suggests starting school-level concerns with school staff and provides board/parent liaison channels. Generic meeting/address wording differs within the page; verify the exact current meeting notice. No complaint, submission or service outcome is established.", "qualification": "Official office guidance suggests starting school-level concerns with school staff and provides board/parent liaison channels. Generic meeting/address wording differs within the page; verify the exact current meeting notice. No complaint, submission or service outcome is established.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/9d71d0bfa20714831dba7968b0b68f2c2d8f43fe9f9ccfb6e29773e3ce2199ed.bin", "sha256": "9d71d0bfa20714831dba7968b0b68f2c2d8f43fe9f9ccfb6e29773e3ce2199ed", "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:48:51.082Z", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM/text and links; not original HTTP response bytes.", "bytes": 3941 }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "dbfc017a8b6ac074a220fe6391fadafebf935d8a091347dd919731f7bf1b076b" }, { "id": "obs-SCHOOL10-PARTICIPATION-e4d222f76d30", "source_id": "SCHOOL10-PARTICIPATION", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.scsk12.org/board/?PN=49", "title": "MSCS · Addressing the Board", "locator": "Business/SpecialCalled meetings, sign-up and public comment headings", "statement": "Official guidance says comments occur at Business/SpecialCalled meetings, not work sessions/committees; check the current dated notice and policy before attending. A calendar entry alone does not establish an item, speaking opportunity or response.", "qualification": "Official guidance says comments occur at Business/SpecialCalled meetings, not work sessions/committees; check the current dated notice and policy before attending. A calendar entry alone does not establish an item, speaking opportunity or response.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/e4d222f76d3088af44acaa51a1e79417bacbe951b49cfe2a3b1e7ba11ae530f9.bin", "sha256": "e4d222f76d3088af44acaa51a1e79417bacbe951b49cfe2a3b1e7ba11ae530f9", "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:48:51.647Z", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM/text and links; not original HTTP response bytes.", "bytes": 5506 }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "caaefe9a6ace9932d0101cc4e71d2a05676fc25e8a5e6f5a68f1117fd7996b6b" }, { "id": "obs-SCHOOL10-NOTICE-a57d99d058fd", "source_id": "SCHOOL10-NOTICE", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "source_url": "https://www.tn.gov/meetings/2026/10/8/educationaloversightboard-of-memphis-shelby-county-schools.html", "title": "Oversight Board · October 8 notice and agenda", "locator": "Dated notice, agenda and public-comment paragraph", "statement": "Past meeting notice, not a current invitation or vote record. Header date range is inconsistent; notice specifies October 8. Two-minute comment limit differs from three-minute rule in the filed ExhibitC. Recording link exists but recording/minutes not reviewed.", "qualification": "Past meeting notice, not a current invitation or vote record. Header date range is inconsistent; notice specifies October 8. Two-minute comment limit differs from three-minute rule in the filed ExhibitC. Recording link exists but recording/minutes not reviewed.", "capture": { "path": "artifacts/government-v10/evidence/a57d99d058fd08b8bba69576a7622246896d42cc83fe7c6d9ca7e7414c9714ca.bin", "sha256": "a57d99d058fd08b8bba69576a7622246896d42cc83fe7c6d9ca7e7414c9714ca", "kind": "public_browser_dom_snapshot", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T13:48:54.093Z", "qualification": "Rendered public DOM/text and links; not original HTTP response bytes.", "bytes": 3034 }, "capture_status": "retained", "reviewed_note_sha256": "6d9bcd0f65cb895fea006ba4b40d0a18d6d7371b226d0a78d22de2c729e76702" } ], "events": [ { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-mayor-person-paul-young", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Paul Young — Mayor of Memphis", "body_node_id": "city-mayor", "person_id": "person-paul-young", "office_id": "office-mayor-of-memphis", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-MAYOR", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": "2024-01-01", "service_end": null, "start_precision": "day", "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Official biography oath assertion, not original individual oath instrument. Scheduled end not qualified." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MAYOR", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MAYOR-9b22872db8f2", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Scheduled exact term expiration and appointment/decision history not fully collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-d1-person-rhonda-logan", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Rhonda Logan — Memphis City Council — District 1", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-rhonda-logan", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-district-1", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-D1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-D1", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D1-de0940a719db", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-d2-person-jerri-green", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Jerri Green — Memphis City Council — District 2", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-jerri-green", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-district-2", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-D2", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-D2", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D2-3f7458af0452", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-d3-person-pearl-eva-walker", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Pearl Eva Walker — Memphis City Council — District 3", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-pearl-eva-walker", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-district-3", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-D3", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-D3", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D3-a05fc7db0b3c", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-d4-person-jana-swearengen-washington", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Jana Swearengen-Washington — Memphis City Council — District 4", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-jana-swearengen-washington", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-district-4", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-D4", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-D4", "CITY7-GUIDE", "CITY7-CHAIR" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D4-0320cc65ae56", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c", "obs-CITY7-CHAIR-755954a147fd" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-d5-person-philip-spinosa", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Philip Spinosa — Memphis City Council — District 5", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-philip-spinosa", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-district-5", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-D5", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-D5", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D5-824e7a91006c", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-d6-person-edmund-ford-sr", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Edmund Ford, Sr. — Memphis City Council — District 6", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-edmund-ford-sr", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-district-6", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-D6", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-D6", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D6-25e8a2cdcbd0", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-d7-person-dr-michalyn-easter-thomas", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Dr. Michalyn Easter-Thomas — Memphis City Council — District 7", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-dr-michalyn-easter-thomas", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-district-7", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-D7", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-D7", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-D7-afeb43c02ae2", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-sd8p1-person-jb-smiley-jr", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "JB Smiley, Jr. — Memphis City Council — Super District 8, Position 1", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-jb-smiley-jr", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-super-district-8-position-1", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-SD8P1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P1", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P1-1deaf2cba0d6", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected.", "Profile header still says Chairman, while biography labels 2024 chair service and dated minutes select Jana for 2026. Current chair header is stale/conflicting." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-sd8p2-person-janika-white", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Janika White — Memphis City Council — Super District 8, Position 2", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-janika-white", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-super-district-8-position-2", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-SD8P2", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P2", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P2-62c8cd7911d0", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-sd8p3-person-yolanda-cooper-sutton", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Yolanda Cooper-Sutton — Memphis City Council — Super District 8, Position 3", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-yolanda-cooper-sutton", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-super-district-8-position-3", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-SD8P3", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P3", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD8P3-e2848a36cfb9", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-sd9p1-person-chase-carlisle", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Chase Carlisle — Memphis City Council — Super District 9, Position 1", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-chase-carlisle", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-super-district-9-position-1", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-SD9P1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P1", "CITY7-GUIDE", "CITY7-CHAIR" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P1-ff1039079277", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c", "obs-CITY7-CHAIR-755954a147fd" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-sd9p2-person-j-ford-canale", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "J. Ford Canale — Memphis City Council — Super District 9, Position 2", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-j-ford-canale", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-super-district-9-position-2", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-SD9P2", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P2", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P2-3ccd8bcfbaab", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected.", "Profile calls Canale Chairman, while dated minutes select Jana for 2026. Do not treat old chair title as current leadership." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-sd9p3-person-dr-jeff-warren", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Dr. Jeff Warren — Memphis City Council — Super District 9, Position 3", "body_node_id": "city-council", "person_id": "person-dr-jeff-warren", "office_id": "office-memphis-city-council-super-district-9-position-3", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-SD9P3", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official-directory assertion; exact current-term oath, end and continuous tenure not established. Election dates remain election dates." }, "summary": "Four-year city term; next election 2027", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-COUNCIL", "CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P3", "CITY7-GUIDE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-COUNCIL-e856e9320f77", "obs-CITY7-PROFILE-SD9P3-126be4ae5a44", "obs-CITY7-GUIDE-f8d10837860c" ], "gaps": [ "Exact current-term service start and scheduled expiration not verified.", "Complete decision and appointment history not collected." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-mlgwceo-person-doug-mcgowen", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Doug McGowen — MLGW President and CEO", "body_node_id": "mlgw-operations", "person_id": "person-doug-mcgowen", "office_id": "office-mlgw-president-and-ceo", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGWCEO", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": "2022-12", "service_end": null, "start_precision": "month", "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Month precision preserved; council approval was earlier than service start." }, "summary": "Executive appointment; current contract or term end not established", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWCEO", "CITY7-MLGWAPPOINT", "CITY7-MLGWGOV" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWCEO-b06f8a802c9e", "obs-CITY7-MLGWAPPOINT-c8afde6987ff", "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc" ], "gaps": [ "Original nomination/confirmation instruments and individual council votes not inspected.", "No exact first day or executive employment contract expiration qualified." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-mlgw-dickson-person-leon-dickson-sr", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Leon Dickson Sr. — MLGW commissioner", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "person_id": "person-leon-dickson-sr", "office_id": "office-category-mlgw-board", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGW-DICKSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current roster observation. Generic three-year guide description is unreconciled and is not assigned to suburban commissioners." }, "summary": "Individual appointment term not established", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWBOARD", "CITY7-MLGWGOV" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWBOARD-87fca7910daf", "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc" ], "gaps": [ "Exact permanent seat identifier, individual nomination/confirmation record and current-term dates not established.", "Governance guide still says five members; current roster lists seven. Generic appointment route does not describe all seven members.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-mlgw-pohlman-person-michael-e-pohlman", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Michael E. Pohlman — MLGW commissioner — Chair", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "person_id": "person-michael-e-pohlman", "office_id": "office-category-mlgw-board", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGW-POHLMAN", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current roster observation. Generic three-year guide description is unreconciled and is not assigned to suburban commissioners." }, "summary": "Individual appointment term not established", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWBOARD", "CITY7-MLGWGOV" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWBOARD-87fca7910daf", "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc" ], "gaps": [ "Exact permanent seat identifier, individual nomination/confirmation record and current-term dates not established.", "Governance guide still says five members; current roster lists seven. Generic appointment route does not describe all seven members.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-mlgw-person-person-carl-person", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Carl Person — MLGW commissioner — Vice Chair", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "person_id": "person-carl-person", "office_id": "office-category-mlgw-board", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGW-PERSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current roster observation. Generic three-year guide description is unreconciled and is not assigned to suburban commissioners." }, "summary": "Individual appointment term not established", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWBOARD", "CITY7-MLGWGOV" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWBOARD-87fca7910daf", "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc" ], "gaps": [ "Exact permanent seat identifier, individual nomination/confirmation record and current-term dates not established.", "Governance guide still says five members; current roster lists seven. Generic appointment route does not describe all seven members.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-mlgw-pesce-person-cheryl-pesce", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Cheryl Pesce — MLGW commissioner", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "person_id": "person-cheryl-pesce", "office_id": "office-category-mlgw-board", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGW-PESCE", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current roster observation. Generic three-year guide description is unreconciled and is not assigned to suburban commissioners." }, "summary": "Individual appointment term not established", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWBOARD", "CITY7-MLGWGOV" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWBOARD-87fca7910daf", "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc" ], "gaps": [ "Exact permanent seat identifier, individual nomination/confirmation record and current-term dates not established.", "Governance guide still says five members; current roster lists seven. Generic appointment route does not describe all seven members.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-mlgw-woods-person-kevin-woods", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Kevin Woods — MLGW commissioner", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "person_id": "person-kevin-woods", "office_id": "office-category-mlgw-board", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGW-WOODS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current roster observation. Generic three-year guide description is unreconciled and is not assigned to suburban commissioners." }, "summary": "Individual appointment term not established", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWBOARD", "CITY7-MLGWGOV" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWBOARD-87fca7910daf", "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc" ], "gaps": [ "Exact permanent seat identifier, individual nomination/confirmation record and current-term dates not established.", "Governance guide still says five members; current roster lists seven. Generic appointment route does not describe all seven members.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-mlgw-lewellen-person-james-lewellen", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "James Lewellen — MLGW commissioner", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "person_id": "person-james-lewellen", "office_id": "office-category-mlgw-board", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGW-LEWELLEN", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current roster observation. Generic three-year guide description is unreconciled and is not assigned to suburban commissioners." }, "summary": "Individual appointment term not established", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWBOARD", "CITY7-MLGWGOV", "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION", "CITY7-LAWINDEX", "CITY7-LAWTEXT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWBOARD-87fca7910daf", "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc", "obs-CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION-7b9ed7219298", "obs-CITY7-LAWINDEX-73acc60f6ca8", "obs-CITY7-LAWTEXT-ca03dc7314c3" ], "gaps": [ "Exact permanent seat identifier, individual nomination/confirmation record and current-term dates not established.", "Governance guide still says five members; current roster lists seven. Generic appointment route does not describe all seven members.", "Announcement date is not separately verified appointment, oath or legal voting-commencement date; enacted chapter retrieval returned 403.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-city7-pos-mlgw-butler-person-john-butler", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "John Butler — MLGW commissioner", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "person_id": "person-john-butler", "office_id": "office-category-mlgw-board", "record_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGW-BUTLER", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current roster observation. Generic three-year guide description is unreconciled and is not assigned to suburban commissioners." }, "summary": "Individual appointment term not established", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWBOARD", "CITY7-MLGWGOV", "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION", "CITY7-LAWINDEX", "CITY7-LAWTEXT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWBOARD-87fca7910daf", "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc", "obs-CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION-7b9ed7219298", "obs-CITY7-LAWINDEX-73acc60f6ca8", "obs-CITY7-LAWTEXT-ca03dc7314c3" ], "gaps": [ "Exact permanent seat identifier, individual nomination/confirmation record and current-term dates not established.", "Governance guide still says five members; current roster lists seven. Generic appointment route does not describe all seven members.", "Announcement date is not separately verified appointment, oath or legal voting-commencement date; enacted chapter retrieval returned 403.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d1-person-rhonda-o-dell", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Rhonda O'Dell — Shelby County Commissioner · District 1", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-rhonda-o-dell", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D1", "COUNTY7-MAPS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D1-10a9d00cd290", "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "District-map directory still names Amber Mills; current member is corroborated by current directory and September 23, 2026 service record." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d2-person-derek-mills", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Derek Mills — Shelby County Commissioner · District 2", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-derek-mills", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D2", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D2", "COUNTY7-MAPS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D2-992e7f50763e", "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "District-map directory still names David C. Bradford, Jr.; current member is corroborated by current directory and September 23, 2026 service record." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d3-person-michele-dial", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Michele Dial — Shelby County Commissioner · District 3", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-michele-dial", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D3", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-MAPS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "Individual profile body could not be retrieved in bounded review; current assignment corroborated by directory and September 23 minutes.", "District-map directory still names Mick Wright; current member is corroborated by current directory and September 23, 2026 service record." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d4-person-mark-billingsley", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Mark Billingsley — Shelby County Commissioner · District 4", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-mark-billingsley", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D4", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-MAPS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "Individual profile body could not be retrieved in bounded review; current assignment corroborated by directory and September 23 minutes.", "District-map directory still names Brandon Morrison; current member is corroborated by current directory and September 23, 2026 service record." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d5-person-shante-k-avant", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Shante K. Avant — Shelby County Commissioner · District 5 · Chairwoman", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-shante-k-avant", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D5", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D5" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D5-d25389ecd457" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "Exact annual chair election resolution and named roll-call not inspected; separate chair term endpoint unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d6-person-charlie-a-caswell-jr", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Charlie A. Caswell, Jr. — Shelby County Commissioner · District 6", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-charlie-a-caswell-jr", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D6", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D6" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D6-9247fcc8ab4a" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "Caswell biography still says Chair Pro Tempore; directory and Brooks profile assign this leadership title to Brooks. Leadership title excluded from Caswell position." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d7-person-henri-e-brooks", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Henri E. Brooks — Shelby County Commissioner · District 7 · Chair Pro Tempore", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-henri-e-brooks", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D7", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D7" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D7-75eb6eb30ce5" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "Brooks is labelled Chair Pro Tempore in the current directory; exact election instrument and leadership term endpoint unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d8-person-will-richardson", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Will Richardson — Shelby County Commissioner · District 8", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-will-richardson", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D8", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D8", "COUNTY7-MAPS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D8-53f375f5b45f", "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "District-map directory still names Mickell Lowery; current member is corroborated by current directory and September 23, 2026 service record." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d9-person-dr-karen-streeter", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Dr. Karen Streeter — Shelby County Commissioner · District 9", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-dr-karen-streeter", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D9", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D9", "COUNTY7-MAPS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D9-b607944d97dc", "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "District-map directory still names Matthew T. Szalaj; current member is corroborated by current directory and September 23, 2026 service record." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d10-person-lashanta-rudd", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Lashanta Rudd — Shelby County Commissioner · District 10", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-lashanta-rudd", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D10", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-MAPS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "Individual profile body could not be retrieved in bounded review; current assignment corroborated by directory and September 23 minutes.", "District-map directory still names Britney Thornton; current member is corroborated by current directory and September 23, 2026 service record." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d11-person-miska-clay-bibbs", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Miska Clay Bibbs — Shelby County Commissioner · District 11", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-miska-clay-bibbs", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D11", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D11" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D11-49eb980785fb" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d12-person-dr-erika-sugarmon", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Dr. Erika Sugarmon — Shelby County Commissioner · District 12", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-dr-erika-sugarmon", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D12", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D12" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D12-df09ea18fe84" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d13-person-amber-huett-garcia", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Amber Huett-Garcia — Shelby County Commissioner · District 13", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "person_id": "person-amber-huett-garcia", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-commissioner", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D13", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Cycle label inferred from current 2026 membership and four-year rule; exact scheduled start/end left unfilled until a current cycle instrument is qualified. Service corroborated September 23, 2026." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D13", "COUNTY7-MAPS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D13-64e118c86425", "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac" ], "gaps": [ "Individual oath and actual term endpoints not located.", "Portrait asset URL and reuse terms not resolved; official image source page available.", "District-map directory still names Michael Whaley; current member is corroborated by current directory and September 23, 2026 service record." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-mayor-pos-person-mickell-m-lowery", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Mickell M. Lowery — Shelby County mayor", "body_node_id": "county-mayor", "person_id": "person-mickell-m-lowery", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-mayor", "record_id": "COUNTY7-MAYOR-POS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": "2026-09-01", "scheduled_end": "2030-08-31", "qualification": "Scheduled cycle derived from mayor biography and charter Section 3.04. Oath reported August 31 is separate from September 1 scheduled commencement; actual qualified service endpoints not independently established." }, "summary": "Scheduled September 1, 2026 – August 31, 2030", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-MAYOR", "COUNTY7-CHARTER" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-MAYOR-6b7eb2a7ed51", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db" ], "gaps": [ "Current charter amendment completeness and actual legal start/end remain unqualified.", "Official portrait source observed; image asset URL not extracted." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-sheriff-pos-person-anthony-j-buckner", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Anthony J. Buckner — Shelby County sheriff", "body_node_id": "sheriff", "person_id": "person-anthony-j-buckner", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-sheriff", "record_id": "COUNTY7-SHERIFF-POS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current office homepage supports holder. Four-year rule supports cycle label; individual oath/legal start and end not established in primary sources reviewed." }, "summary": "2026–2030 election cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-SHERIFF", "COUNTY7-SHERIFF-STALE", "COUNTY7-BUCKNER-PROFILE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-SHERIFF-adeeb184c017", "obs-COUNTY7-SHERIFF-STALE-26489edb8573", "obs-COUNTY7-BUCKNER-PROFILE-fb2faba3d2f7", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db" ], "gaps": [ "Linked sheriff biography still names Floyd Bonner.", "Buckner command staff text still describes Chief Deputy despite Sheriff heading.", "Current oath, scheduled exact endpoints and portrait asset URL unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-da-pos-person-steve-mulroy", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Steve Mulroy — District attorney general · 30th Judicial District", "body_node_id": "district-attorney", "person_id": "person-steve-mulroy", "office_id": "office-district-attorney-general", "record_id": "COUNTY7-DA-POS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current agency biography supports officeholder; office is separately elected rather than appointed by county mayor." }, "summary": "Elected August 2022 · exact term endpoints pending", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-DA" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-DA-4973f7043fdf" ], "gaps": [ "Eight-year term/legal endpoint not independently qualified in this source pass.", "Portrait image asset URL unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-chief-staff-person-felecia-higgs-walker", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Felecia Higgs Walker — Chief of Staff · appointment announced", "body_node_id": "county-executive", "person_id": "person-felecia-higgs-walker", "office_id": "office-chief-of-staff", "record_id": "COUNTY7-CHIEF-STAFF", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Appointment announcement is tracked separately from confirmed or commenced service." }, "summary": "Announced September 15, 2026 · tenure not established", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS-abf2ca8748d0" ], "gaps": [ "Appointment announcement only; actual commencement and any fixed term unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-cao-person-maura-black-sullivan", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Maura Black Sullivan — Chief Administrative Officer · appointment announced", "body_node_id": "county-executive", "person_id": "person-maura-black-sullivan", "office_id": "office-chief-administrative-officer", "record_id": "COUNTY7-CAO", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Appointment announcement is tracked separately from confirmed or commenced service." }, "summary": "Announced September 15, 2026 · tenure not established", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS", "COUNTY7-CHARTER" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS-abf2ca8748d0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db" ], "gaps": [ "Appointment announcement only; actual commencement and any fixed term unresolved.", "Charter Section 2.12 calls for commission consent to CAO nomination; confirmation resolution and vote not reviewed." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-cfo-person-brian-collins", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Brian Collins — Chief Financial Officer · appointment announced", "body_node_id": "county-executive", "person_id": "person-brian-collins", "office_id": "office-chief-financial-officer", "record_id": "COUNTY7-CFO", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Appointment announcement is tracked separately from confirmed or commenced service." }, "summary": "Announced September 15, 2026 · tenure not established", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS-abf2ca8748d0" ], "gaps": [ "Appointment announcement only; actual commencement and any fixed term unresolved.", "Photo alt text says Bill Collins while appointment heading says Brian Collins; image withheld pending identity verification." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-county-public-works-person-david-c-bradford-jr", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "David C. Bradford, Jr. — County Director of Public Works · appointment announced", "body_node_id": "county-executive", "person_id": "person-david-c-bradford-jr", "office_id": "office-county-director-of-public-works", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COUNTY-PUBLIC-WORKS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Appointment announcement is tracked separately from confirmed or commenced service." }, "summary": "Announced September 15, 2026 · tenure not established", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS-abf2ca8748d0" ], "gaps": [ "Appointment announcement only; actual commencement and any fixed term unresolved.", "Prior District 2 commissioner service is historical; current District 2 commissioner is Derek Mills." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-hr-person-crystal-r-oliver", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Crystal R. Oliver — Director of Human Resources · appointment announced", "body_node_id": "county-executive", "person_id": "person-crystal-r-oliver", "office_id": "office-director-of-human-resources", "record_id": "COUNTY7-HR", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Appointment announcement is tracked separately from confirmed or commenced service." }, "summary": "Announced September 15, 2026 · tenure not established", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS-abf2ca8748d0" ], "gaps": [ "Appointment announcement only; actual commencement and any fixed term unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-judge-hagerman-person-paul-hagerman", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Paul Hagerman — Criminal court judge · appointment announced", "body_node_id": "courts", "person_id": "person-paul-hagerman", "office_id": "office-category-courts", "record_id": "COUNTY7-JUDGE-HAGERMAN", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Governor announcement supports appointment, not independently qualified commenced service." }, "summary": "Appointed September 15, 2026 · term endpoints pending", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS-ee2dd4fa7df6" ], "gaps": [ "Exact division/seat, oath, commencement, term end and portrait unresolved.", "Other criminal court judges not researched in this bounded expansion.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-judge-young-person-marques-young", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Marques Young — Criminal court judge · appointment announced", "body_node_id": "courts", "person_id": "person-marques-young", "office_id": "office-category-courts", "record_id": "COUNTY7-JUDGE-YOUNG", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Governor announcement supports appointment, not independently qualified commenced service." }, "summary": "Appointed September 15, 2026 · term endpoints pending", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS-ee2dd4fa7df6" ], "gaps": [ "Exact division/seat, oath, commencement, term end and portrait unresolved.", "Other criminal court judges not researched in this bounded expansion.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-trustee-pos-person-joseph-lee-iii", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Joseph Lee III — Shelby County trustee", "body_node_id": "county-trustee", "person_id": "person-joseph-lee-iii", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-trustee", "record_id": "COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-POS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current dedicated office announcement dated September 1, 2026 preferred to stale county directory; exact endpoints unqualified." }, "summary": "2026–2030 cycle · four-year office", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-CURRENT", "COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-STALE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-CURRENT-943209db8a4a", "obs-COUNTY7-TRUSTEE-STALE-676fec97729d", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db" ], "gaps": [ "County staff directory still names Regina Morrison Newman.", "Exact oath/endpoints and portrait asset unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-county7-assessor-pos-person-javier-bailey-sr", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Javier Bailey, Sr. — Shelby County assessor of property", "body_node_id": "county-assessor", "person_id": "person-javier-bailey-sr", "office_id": "office-shelby-county-assessor-of-property", "record_id": "COUNTY7-ASSESSOR-POS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official directory supports holder; charter four-year rule recorded without constructing individual endpoints." }, "summary": "Four-year office · exact current term dates pending", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-ASSESSOR", "COUNTY7-CHARTER" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ASSESSOR-73e0ad7b74ac", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db" ], "gaps": [ "Current oath and election instrument, exact term dates and portrait asset unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-school-d1-person-michelle-robinson-mckissack", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Michelle Robinson McKissack — MSCS school board — District 1", "body_node_id": "mscs-board", "person_id": "person-michelle-robinson-mckissack", "office_id": "office-mscs-school-board-district-1", "record_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL-D1", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Named in the current district directory; exact election cohort, oath and tenure endpoints unverified." }, "summary": "Individual term dates not yet qualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SCHOOL" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c" ], "gaps": [ "Individual term start/end and decision history not collected.", "2026 oversight law and operative court orders may constrain powers." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-school-d2-person-natalie-mckinney", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Natalie McKinney — MSCS school board — District 2", "body_node_id": "mscs-board", "person_id": "person-natalie-mckinney", "office_id": "office-mscs-school-board-district-2", "record_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL-D2", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Named in the current district directory; exact election cohort, oath and tenure endpoints unverified." }, "summary": "Individual term dates not yet qualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SCHOOL" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c" ], "gaps": [ "Individual term start/end and decision history not collected.", "2026 oversight law and operative court orders may constrain powers." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-school-d3-person-stephanie-p-love", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Stephanie P. Love — MSCS school board — District 3", "body_node_id": "mscs-board", "person_id": "person-stephanie-p-love", "office_id": "office-mscs-school-board-district-3", "record_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL-D3", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Named in the current district directory; exact election cohort, oath and tenure endpoints unverified." }, "summary": "Individual term dates not yet qualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SCHOOL" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c" ], "gaps": [ "Individual term start/end and decision history not collected.", "2026 oversight law and operative court orders may constrain powers." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-school-d4-person-tamarques-porter", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Tamarques Porter — MSCS school board — District 4 · Chair", "body_node_id": "mscs-board", "person_id": "person-tamarques-porter", "office_id": "office-mscs-school-board-district-4", "record_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL-D4", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Named in the current district directory; exact election cohort, oath and tenure endpoints unverified." }, "summary": "Individual term dates not yet qualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SCHOOL" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c" ], "gaps": [ "Individual term start/end and decision history not collected.", "2026 oversight law and operative court orders may constrain powers." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-school-d5-person-sable-otey", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Sable Otey — MSCS school board — District 5 · Vice chair", "body_node_id": "mscs-board", "person_id": "person-sable-otey", "office_id": "office-mscs-school-board-district-5", "record_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL-D5", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Named in the current district directory; exact election cohort, oath and tenure endpoints unverified." }, "summary": "Individual term dates not yet qualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SCHOOL" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c" ], "gaps": [ "Individual term start/end and decision history not collected.", "2026 oversight law and operative court orders may constrain powers." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-school-d6-person-t-l-harris", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "T.L. Harris — MSCS school board — District 6", "body_node_id": "mscs-board", "person_id": "person-t-l-harris", "office_id": "office-mscs-school-board-district-6", "record_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL-D6", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Named in the current district directory; exact election cohort, oath and tenure endpoints unverified." }, "summary": "Individual term dates not yet qualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SCHOOL" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c" ], "gaps": [ "Individual term start/end and decision history not collected.", "2026 oversight law and operative court orders may constrain powers." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-school-d7-person-towanna-murphy", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Towanna Murphy — MSCS school board — District 7", "body_node_id": "mscs-board", "person_id": "person-towanna-murphy", "office_id": "office-mscs-school-board-district-7", "record_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL-D7", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Named in the current district directory; exact election cohort, oath and tenure endpoints unverified." }, "summary": "Individual term dates not yet qualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SCHOOL" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c" ], "gaps": [ "Individual term start/end and decision history not collected.", "2026 oversight law and operative court orders may constrain powers." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-school-d8-person-tanya-frey", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Tanya Frey — MSCS school board — District 8", "body_node_id": "mscs-board", "person_id": "person-tanya-frey", "office_id": "office-mscs-school-board-district-8", "record_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL-D8", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Named in the current district directory; exact election cohort, oath and tenure endpoints unverified." }, "summary": "Individual term dates not yet qualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SCHOOL" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c" ], "gaps": [ "Individual term start/end and decision history not collected.", "2026 oversight law and operative court orders may constrain powers." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-school-d9-person-joyce-dorse-coleman", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Joyce Dorse Coleman — MSCS school board — District 9", "body_node_id": "mscs-board", "person_id": "person-joyce-dorse-coleman", "office_id": "office-mscs-school-board-district-9", "record_id": "ROOT7-SCHOOL-D9", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Named in the current district directory; exact election cohort, oath and tenure endpoints unverified." }, "summary": "Individual term dates not yet qualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SCHOOL" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SCHOOL-8a98f6cc046c" ], "gaps": [ "Individual term start/end and decision history not collected.", "2026 oversight law and operative court orders may constrain powers." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-super-pos-person-dr-roderick-f-richmond", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Dr. Roderick F. Richmond — MSCS superintendent", "body_node_id": "mscs-director", "person_id": "person-dr-roderick-f-richmond", "office_id": "office-mscs-superintendent", "record_id": "ROOT7-SUPER-POS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current official profile identifies superintendent; appointment resolution and contract were not reviewed." }, "summary": "Appointed role · exact service dates not verified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-SUPER" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-SUPER-0a05ad5e3413" ], "gaps": [ "Original appointment, contract term and exact start/end unverified.", "Latest operative school oversight orders remain unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-oversight-burroughs-person-tyrone-burroughs", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Tyrone Burroughs — MSCS oversight board — Governor appointee", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "person_id": "person-tyrone-burroughs", "office_id": "office-category-mscs-oversight", "record_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-BURROUGHS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Five Governor appointees only. Individually numbered seats and continued current service not qualified." }, "summary": "Appointment announced May 22, 2026", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-7b6fca01bb92" ], "gaps": [ "No oath, original appointment instrument or current complete membership verified.", "Four speaker appointees not collected; current powers and operative court orders unresolved.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-oversight-hopson-person-dorsey-hopson", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Dorsey Hopson — MSCS oversight board — Governor appointee", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "person_id": "person-dorsey-hopson", "office_id": "office-category-mscs-oversight", "record_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-HOPSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Five Governor appointees only. Individually numbered seats and continued current service not qualified." }, "summary": "Appointment announced May 22, 2026", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-7b6fca01bb92" ], "gaps": [ "No oath, original appointment instrument or current complete membership verified.", "Four speaker appointees not collected; current powers and operative court orders unresolved.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-oversight-mckinney-person-shanea-mckinney", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Shanea McKinney — MSCS oversight board — Governor appointee", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "person_id": "person-shanea-mckinney", "office_id": "office-category-mscs-oversight", "record_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-MCKINNEY", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Five Governor appointees only. Individually numbered seats and continued current service not qualified." }, "summary": "Appointment announced May 22, 2026", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-7b6fca01bb92" ], "gaps": [ "No oath, original appointment instrument or current complete membership verified.", "Four speaker appointees not collected; current powers and operative court orders unresolved.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-oversight-powers-person-nisha-powers", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Nisha Powers — MSCS oversight board — Governor appointee", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "person_id": "person-nisha-powers", "office_id": "office-category-mscs-oversight", "record_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-POWERS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Five Governor appointees only. Individually numbered seats and continued current service not qualified." }, "summary": "Appointment announced May 22, 2026", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-7b6fca01bb92" ], "gaps": [ "No oath, original appointment instrument or current complete membership verified.", "Four speaker appointees not collected; current powers and operative court orders unresolved.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-oversight-robertson-person-beverly-robertson", "kind": "appointment_observation", "title": "Beverly Robertson — MSCS oversight board — Governor appointee", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "person_id": "person-beverly-robertson", "office_id": "office-category-mscs-oversight", "record_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-ROBERTSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Five Governor appointees only. Individually numbered seats and continued current service not qualified." }, "summary": "Appointment announced May 22, 2026", "status": "announced_appointment", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-7b6fca01bb92" ], "gaps": [ "No oath, original appointment instrument or current complete membership verified.", "Four speaker appointees not collected; current powers and operative court orders unresolved.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-county-wallace-person-desiree-lyles-wallace", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Desiree Lyles Wallace — LUCB county-appointed membership · Vice chair", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-desiree-lyles-wallace", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-COUNTY-WALLACE", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five county appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-county-mckinnon-person-j-c-mckinnon", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "J.C. McKinnon — LUCB county-appointed membership", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-j-c-mckinnon", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-COUNTY-MCKINNON", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five county appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-county-o-connell-person-jennifer-o-connell", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Jennifer O’Connell — LUCB county-appointed membership", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-jennifer-o-connell", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-COUNTY-O’CONNELL", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five county appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-county-thomas-person-darrell-thomas", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Darrell Thomas — LUCB county-appointed membership", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-darrell-thomas", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-COUNTY-THOMAS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five county appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-county-wilbanks-person-lisa-wilbanks", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Lisa Wilbanks — LUCB county-appointed membership · Consent Agenda Committee chair", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-lisa-wilbanks", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-COUNTY-WILBANKS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five county appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-city-gill-person-brown-gill", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Brown Gill — LUCB city-appointed membership", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-brown-gill", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-CITY-GILL", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five city appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-city-orgel-person-benjamin-orgel", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Benjamin Orgel — LUCB city-appointed membership", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-benjamin-orgel", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-CITY-ORGEL", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five city appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-city-norman-person-keith-norman", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Keith Norman — LUCB city-appointed membership", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-keith-norman", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-CITY-NORMAN", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five city appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-city-sharp-person-mary-sharp", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Mary Sharp — LUCB city-appointed membership · Chair", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-mary-sharp", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-CITY-SHARP", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five city appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-lucb-city-winter-person-michael-winter", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Michael Winter — LUCB city-appointed membership", "body_node_id": "lucb", "person_id": "person-michael-winter", "office_id": "office-category-lucb", "record_id": "ROOT7-LUCB-CITY-WINTER", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current named membership within five city appointments; permanent numbered seat not established." }, "summary": "Three-year term rule · individual dates unknown", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Exact appointment/confirmation dates and individual service endpoints unverified.", "Permanent unique seat identity is not established; this is a sourced membership/appointment record, not an invented numbered seat." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-gov-pos-person-bill-lee", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Bill Lee — Governor of Tennessee", "body_node_id": "state-governor", "person_id": "person-bill-lee", "office_id": "office-governor-of-tennessee", "record_id": "ROOT7-GOV-POS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Official biography supports year-level historical tenure; current profile observed October 14." }, "summary": "Governor since 2019 · exact current-term dates unqualified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-GOVERNOR" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-GOVERNOR-8ad51418e098" ], "gaps": [ "Original oath and exact current-term endpoints not reviewed." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-tdot-pos-person-will-reid-p-e", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "Will Reid, P.E. — Tennessee transportation commissioner", "body_node_id": "tdot", "person_id": "person-will-reid-p-e", "office_id": "office-tennessee-transportation-commissioner", "record_id": "ROOT7-TDOT-POS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "July 2 announcement explicitly states July 10 effective appointment; profile and cabinet currently corroborate commissioner." }, "summary": "Appointment effective July 10, 2025", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-TDOT", "ROOT7-CABINET", "ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-TDOT-34a1cb3fd59a", "obs-ROOT7-CABINET-63e7a01bc52b", "obs-ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINT-e315ec5f3750" ], "gaps": [ "Original oath and actual service-end not established." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-service-v7-root7-tdec-pos-person-david-w-salyers", "kind": "roster_observation", "title": "David W. Salyers — Tennessee environment and conservation commissioner", "body_node_id": "tdec", "person_id": "person-david-w-salyers", "office_id": "office-tennessee-environment-and-conservation-commissioner", "record_id": "ROOT7-TDEC-POS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "valid_time": { "service_start": null, "service_end": null, "start_precision": null, "scheduled_start": null, "scheduled_end": null, "qualification": "Current cabinet directory supports name/title. Direct individual profile retrieval failed; older appointment-year claim not adopted as exact service start." }, "summary": "Appointed role · individual dates unverified", "status": "current_directory_observation", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-CABINET" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-CABINET-63e7a01bc52b" ], "gaps": [ "Original appointment, individual term and exact start/end not reviewed." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-APPOINTMENT-EVENT", "kind": "appointment_announcement", "title": "Five school oversight appointments announced", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "record_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-APPOINTMENT-EVENT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2026-05-22", "effective_date": null, "summary": "Governor Lee named five appointees. This establishes an announcement and the named people, not a complete current board or every legal power.", "status": "Appointment announcement; current continued service not verified", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-7b6fca01bb92" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "Tyrone Burroughs", "position_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-BURROUGHS", "role_at_event": "Governor-appointed oversight board appointee", "action": "appointment announced" }, { "person_name": "Dorsey Hopson", "position_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-HOPSON", "role_at_event": "Governor-appointed oversight board appointee", "action": "appointment announced" }, { "person_name": "Shanea McKinney", "position_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-MCKINNEY", "role_at_event": "Governor-appointed oversight board appointee", "action": "appointment announced" }, { "person_name": "Nisha Powers", "position_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-POWERS", "role_at_event": "Governor-appointed oversight board appointee", "action": "appointment announced" }, { "person_name": "Beverly Robertson", "position_id": "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-ROBERTSON", "role_at_event": "Governor-appointed oversight board appointee", "action": "appointment announced" } ], "gaps": [ "Complete nine-member roster, original instruments, actual qualification and current operative court orders unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINTMENT-EVENT", "kind": "appointment_announcement", "title": "Will Reid appointed TDOT commissioner", "body_node_id": "tdot", "record_id": "ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINTMENT-EVENT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2025-07-02", "effective_date": "2025-07-10", "summary": "Governor Lee announced Reid as successor to Butch Eley. The appointment was stated to take effect July 10, eight days after the announcement.", "status": "Announced appointment with stated effective date; current role corroborated", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINT", "ROOT7-TDOT", "ROOT7-CABINET" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINT-e315ec5f3750", "obs-ROOT7-TDOT-34a1cb3fd59a", "obs-ROOT7-CABINET-63e7a01bc52b" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "Bill Lee", "role_at_event": "Tennessee governor", "action": "announced appointment" }, { "person_name": "Will Reid, P.E.", "position_id": "ROOT7-TDOT-POS", "role_at_event": "TDOT commissioner appointee", "action": "appointed effective July 10" } ], "gaps": [ "Original oath instrument and actual service endpoint not reviewed." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-COUNTY7-EXECUTIVE-APPOINTMENTS", "kind": "appointment_announcement", "title": "First five county executive appointments announced", "body_node_id": "county-mayor", "record_id": "COUNTY7-EXECUTIVE-APPOINTMENTS", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2026-09-15", "effective_date": null, "summary": "Mayor Lowery announced five administrative appointees. Their role assignments are displayed as announced rather than proof of qualification or commenced service.", "status": "Announcement; confirmation and commencement unresolved", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS", "COUNTY7-CHARTER" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-APPOINTMENTS-abf2ca8748d0", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "Mickell M. Lowery", "position_id": "COUNTY7-MAYOR-POS", "role_at_event": "Shelby County mayor", "action": "announced appointments" }, { "person_name": "Felecia Higgs Walker", "position_id": "COUNTY7-CHIEF-STAFF", "role_at_event": "Chief of Staff appointee", "action": "appointment announced" }, { "person_name": "Maura Black Sullivan", "position_id": "COUNTY7-CAO", "role_at_event": "Chief Administrative Officer appointee", "action": "appointment announced" }, { "person_name": "Brian Collins", "position_id": "COUNTY7-CFO", "role_at_event": "Chief Financial Officer appointee", "action": "appointment announced" }, { "person_name": "David C. Bradford, Jr.", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COUNTY-PUBLIC-WORKS", "role_at_event": "County Director of Public Works appointee", "action": "appointment announced" }, { "person_name": "Crystal R. Oliver", "position_id": "COUNTY7-HR", "role_at_event": "Director of Human Resources appointee", "action": "appointment announced" } ], "gaps": [ "CAO consent required in linked charter; confirmation instrument not reviewed.", "Individual start dates and tenure endpoints unestablished." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS-EVENT", "kind": "appointment_announcement", "title": "Two new criminal-court judges appointed", "body_node_id": "courts", "record_id": "COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS-EVENT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2026-09-15", "effective_date": null, "summary": "Governor Bill Lee appointed Paul Hagerman and Marques Young to new judicial positions serving Shelby County.", "status": "Governor appointment announcement; service commencement unqualified", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS-ee2dd4fa7df6" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "Bill Lee", "role_at_event": "Tennessee governor", "action": "announced judicial appointments" }, { "person_name": "Paul Hagerman", "position_id": "COUNTY7-JUDGE-HAGERMAN", "role_at_event": "Criminal court judicial appointee", "action": "appointed" }, { "person_name": "Marques Young", "position_id": "COUNTY7-JUDGE-YOUNG", "role_at_event": "Criminal court judicial appointee", "action": "appointed" } ], "gaps": [ "Division identifiers, qualification/oath, commencement and term endpoints unresolved." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-CITY7-MLGW-CEO-APPOINTMENT-EVENT", "kind": "appointment_announcement", "title": "Council approval of MLGW CEO reported", "body_node_id": "mlgw-operations", "record_id": "CITY7-MLGW-CEO-APPOINTMENT-EVENT", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2022-11-01", "effective_date": null, "summary": "MLGW reports council approval of Doug McGowen following Mayor Jim Strickland’s nomination. The CEO biography dates service to December 2022, at month precision.", "status": "Council approval reported in official release; roll call not collected", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWAPPOINT", "CITY7-MLGWCEO" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWAPPOINT-c8afde6987ff", "obs-CITY7-MLGWCEO-b06f8a802c9e" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "Doug McGowen", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGWCEO", "role_at_event": "MLGW president/CEO appointee", "action": "appointment approved, according to official release" }, { "person_name": "Jim Strickland", "role_at_event": "Memphis mayor in 2022", "action": "nominated" } ], "gaps": [ "Original confirmation instrument and individual roll call not collected.", "Exact service-start day and contract endpoint not established." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-CITY7-DEC-CHAIR2026", "kind": "collective_decision", "title": "Select 2026 Council chair and vicechair", "body_node_id": "city-council", "record_id": "CITY7-DEC-CHAIR2026", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2025-11-04", "effective_date": null, "summary": "Council selected Jana Swearengen-Washington as 2026 chair and Chase Carlisle as 2026 vicechair by acclamation.", "status": "selected_by_acclamation", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-CHAIR" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-CHAIR-755954a147fd" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "JB Smiley, Jr.", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-SD8P1", "action": "nominated_and_moved_selection_by_acclamation", "role_at_event": "Council member" }, { "person_name": "Jana Swearengen-Washington", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-D4", "action": "selected_as_2026_chair", "role_at_event": "2025 vicechair; chair-elect for 2026" }, { "person_name": "Chase Carlisle", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-SD9P1", "action": "selected_as_2026_vicechair", "role_at_event": "Council member; vicechair-elect for 2026" } ], "gaps": [ "Acclamation is not a named individual rollcall.", "Selection date is not individual seat commencement." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-CITY7-DEC-SUP2608", "kind": "collective_decision", "title": "Special-use permit SUP 26-08 —2465 Milbrook Avenue", "body_node_id": "city-council", "record_id": "CITY7-DEC-SUP2608", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2026-07-07", "effective_date": null, "summary": "Council approved item 3 under Unified Development Code chapter 9.6;9 named ayes, White did not cast a vote,3 members absent.", "status": "approved", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-JULY7" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-JULY7-6f314e0c7959" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "Rhonda Logan", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-D1", "action": "voted", "role_at_event": "Council member", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Jerri Green", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-D2", "action": "absent", "role_at_event": "Council member" }, { "person_name": "Pearl Eva Walker", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-D3", "action": "absent", "role_at_event": "Council member" }, { "person_name": "Jana Swearengen-Washington", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-D4", "action": "voted", "role_at_event": "Council chair", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Philip Spinosa", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-D5", "action": "voted", "role_at_event": "Council member", "vote": "aye", "motion_role": "mover" }, { "person_name": "Edmund Ford, Sr.", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-D6", "action": "voted", "role_at_event": "Council member", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Dr. Michalyn Easter-Thomas", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-D7", "action": "voted", "role_at_event": "Council member", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "JB Smiley, Jr.", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-SD8P1", "action": "voted", "role_at_event": "Council member", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Janika White", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-SD8P2", "action": "did_not_cast_vote", "role_at_event": "Council member" }, { "person_name": "Yolanda Cooper-Sutton", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-SD8P3", "action": "voted", "role_at_event": "Council member", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Chase Carlisle", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-SD9P1", "action": "absent", "role_at_event": "Council member" }, { "person_name": "J. Ford Canale", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-SD9P2", "action": "voted", "role_at_event": "Council member", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Dr. Jeff Warren", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-SD9P3", "action": "voted", "role_at_event": "Council member", "vote": "aye", "motion_role": "seconder" } ], "gaps": [ "Numeric aye count is calculated from names, not printed tally.", "Original adopted permit and implementing conditions not inspected; approval does not establish construction or effects." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-CITY7-DEC-MLGWEXPANSION", "kind": "agency_announcement", "title": "MLGW announces seven voting commissioners", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "record_id": "CITY7-DEC-MLGWEXPANSION", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2026-07-15", "effective_date": null, "summary": "MLGW reports former suburban advisors Butler and Lewellen now have votes, expanding voting membership to seven.", "status": "official_transition_announcement", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION", "CITY7-MLGWBOARD", "CITY7-LAWINDEX", "CITY7-LAWTEXT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION-7b9ed7219298", "obs-CITY7-MLGWBOARD-87fca7910daf", "obs-CITY7-LAWINDEX-73acc60f6ca8", "obs-CITY7-LAWTEXT-ca03dc7314c3" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "John Butler", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGW-BUTLER", "action": "reported_as_voting_commissioner", "role_at_event": "Former suburban advisor, now voting commissioner" }, { "person_name": "James Lewellen", "position_id": "CITY7-POS-MLGW-LEWELLEN", "action": "reported_as_voting_commissioner", "role_at_event": "Former suburban advisor, now voting commissioner" } ], "gaps": [ "Announcement, not a board motion or named vote.", "Precise individual appointment/confirmation dates and terms not qualified.", "Enacted operating-document retrieval returned 403." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-COUNTY7-COMMITTEE-JAIL-FOOD", "kind": "collective_decision", "title": "Jail food-service contract motion", "body_node_id": "county-commission", "record_id": "COUNTY7-COMMITTEE-JAIL-FOOD", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2026-09-23", "effective_date": null, "summary": "Committee approved forwarding an Aramark food-service contract motion for the Sheriff’s Office; this does not establish contract execution or delivery.", "status": "Committee motion passed 13–0; full commission outcome not reviewed", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "Rhonda O'Dell", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D1", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 1", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Derek Mills", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D2", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 2", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Michele Dial", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D3", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 3", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Mark Billingsley", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D4", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 4", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Shante K. Avant", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D5", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 5", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Charlie A. Caswell, Jr.", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D6", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 6", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Henri E. Brooks", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D7", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 7", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Will Richardson", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D8", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 8", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Dr. Karen Streeter", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D9", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 9", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Lashanta Rudd", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D10", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 10", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Miska Clay Bibbs", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D11", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 11", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Dr. Erika Sugarmon", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D12", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 12", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" }, { "person_name": "Amber Huett-Garcia", "position_id": "COUNTY7-COMMISSION-D13", "role_at_event": "Shelby County Commissioner, District 13", "action": "voted", "vote": "aye" } ], "gaps": [ "Final full commission adoption, executed contract and implementation results not reviewed." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-COUNTY7-DA-POLICY-2024", "kind": "agency_policy_statement", "title": "DA declines a considered prosecution alternative", "body_node_id": "district-attorney", "record_id": "COUNTY7-DA-POLICY-2024", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": "2024-06-17", "effective_date": null, "summary": "Mulroy announced he would not pursue a considered alternative for a narrow class of nonviolent firearm cases. The release describes consideration and a decision, not enacted legislation.", "status": "Historical agency policy statement", "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-DA-POLICY" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-DA-POLICY-aa5bf7ef82de" ], "participants": [ { "person_name": "Steve Mulroy", "position_id": "COUNTY7-DA-POS", "role_at_event": "District attorney general", "action": "announced decision not to pursue considered program" } ], "gaps": [ "Current policy continuity, specific case outcomes and effects not established." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-policy-mlgw1116", "kind": "policy_qualification", "title": "MLGW board structure: legal instrument qualification", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Operative policy scope unresolved", "summary": "The legislature bill index identifies Public Chapter 1116; the current roster and July 15 release support seven voting members. Final act text was not readable in this review.", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-LAWINDEX", "CITY7-LAWTEXT", "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-LAWINDEX-73acc60f6ca8", "obs-CITY7-LAWTEXT-ca03dc7314c3", "obs-CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION-7b9ed7219298" ], "gaps": [ "Enacted text retrieval returned 403; do not treat fiscal summaries or draft amendments as operative text.", "Exact individual seat terms, appointment instruments and legal commencement remain to be checked." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-policy-school1057", "kind": "policy_qualification", "title": "School oversight: statutory and court-order qualification", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Operative policy scope unresolved", "summary": "The governor announced appointments and supporting legislative text describes an oversight structure. Final Public Chapter 1057 text and latest operative court orders remain unqualified.", "source_ids": [ "CRCO09", "CRCO10", "CRCO11" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CRCO09-5de7c915892e", "obs-CRCO10-c4d8e4cdad93", "obs-CRCO11-4b1f56c108e3" ], "gaps": [ "An announcement or agenda does not establish current legal power or actual meeting action.", "Final enacted text, later amendments, court orders and adopted procedures require review." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "history-COURT10-STATUSQUO-ORDER", "kind": "judicial_order", "title": "July 1 court order preserves the pre-act status quo", "body_node_id": "mscs-federal-court", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "event_date": "2026-07-01", "effective_date": null, "status": "judicial_order_read", "summary": "Document22 orders the parties to maintain the status quo before enactment of Public Chapter 1057 pending consideration of injunctive relief. This is a dated court action; later orders must govern any change.", "source_ids": [ "COURT10-JULY1", "COURT10-DOCKET" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COURT10-JULY1-1f5cf7933183", "obs-COURT10-DOCKET-8abbbb9641aa" ], "gaps": [ "Later official docket completeness and any subsequent lifting/modification remain unqualified." ], "corrects": [], "supersedes": [], "record_id": "COURT10-STATUSQUO-ORDER" }, { "id": "history-COURT10-DISSOLUTION-HELD", "kind": "judicial_order", "title": "October 5 court order holds dissolution in abeyance", "body_node_id": "mscs-federal-court", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "event_date": "2026-10-05", "effective_date": null, "status": "judicial_order_read", "summary": "Document79 defers the dissolution request and directs the chair to submit sworn readiness. It dismisses the named state leaders in their stated capacities while reserving other matters; it does not lift the status-quo order.", "source_ids": [ "COURT10-OCT5", "COURT10-DOCKET" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COURT10-OCT5-8c5e5abcdf65", "obs-COURT10-DOCKET-8abbbb9641aa" ], "gaps": [ "Date is filing date; docket signed-date label and October 2 hearing context remain separate.", "No current-authority change is inferred from a deferred motion." ], "corrects": [], "supersedes": [], "record_id": "COURT10-DISSOLUTION-HELD" }, { "id": "history-COURT10-READINESS-FILED", "kind": "sworn_filing", "title": "October 13 sworn filing: chair declares readiness", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "event_date": "2026-10-13", "effective_date": null, "status": "sworn_party_statement_read_not_a_court_ruling", "summary": "Billy Orgel identifies himself as chair and declares the Board ready. His declaration reports October 8 organizational actions and includes notice, job description, procedures and contract workflow exhibits. These attributed actions are not a lifting order, a verified individual roll call or proof of delivered services.", "source_ids": [ "COURT10-DECL82", "COURT10-EXH-B", "COURT10-EXH-C", "COURT10-EXH-D", "COURT10-DOCKET" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COURT10-DECL82-fa25d797690b", "obs-COURT10-EXH-B-7d1ac25e7867", "obs-COURT10-EXH-C-7d1ac25e7867", "obs-COURT10-EXH-D-7d1ac25e7867", "obs-COURT10-DOCKET-8abbbb9641aa" ], "gaps": [ "The filed procedures contain blank adoption/certification, address and schedule fields. Exact October 8 motions/votes and later signed amendments remain unreviewed. Follow current dated notices; public-comment timing differs between the October 8 notice and filed rules.", "No independent October 8 minutes/recording review or actual hire/contract award/outcome qualification." ], "corrects": [], "supersedes": [], "record_id": "COURT10-READINESS-FILED" }, { "id": "history-policy-school1057-v10", "kind": "policy_qualification", "title": "Final school act qualified; court-dependent exercise retained", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "event_date": "2026-04-22", "effective_date": "2026-05-22", "status": "Final enacted text read; current exercise conditional", "summary": "Signed final Chapter 1057 establishes passageApril22 and approval/effectivenessMay22. That law date is separate from court-limited operation and the post-bar four-year operating clock. Previously unread final-text gap is corrected; later-order and implemented-procedure gaps remain.", "source_ids": [ "SCHOOL10-ACT", "SCHOOL10-BILL", "COURT10-JULY1", "COURT10-OCT5", "COURT10-DECL82", "COURT10-DOCKET" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-SCHOOL10-ACT-fa72578887ac", "obs-SCHOOL10-BILL-116e3844db37", "obs-COURT10-OCT5-8c5e5abcdf65", "obs-COURT10-DECL82-fa25d797690b", "obs-COURT10-JULY1-1f5cf7933183", "obs-COURT10-DOCKET-8abbbb9641aa" ], "gaps": [ "The July 1 order requires the pre-act status quo; the October 5 order holds the dissolution request in abeyance. The October 13 chair declaration states readiness, but is not a lifting order. The public docket is known through October 13; a later official ruling remains unqualified.", "The filed procedures contain blank adoption/certification, address and schedule fields. Exact October 8 motions/votes and later signed amendments remain unreviewed. Follow current dated notices; public-comment timing differs between the October 8 notice and filed rules." ], "corrects": [ "history-policy-school1057" ], "supersedes": [] } ], "collection_changes": [ { "id": "collection-change-v7-people", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Added officeholders, images and selected recorded actions", "body_node_id": null, "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed collection changed", "summary": "The previous chart contained responsibilities and relationships. This release adds 75 sourced position records and 10 selected actions. It does not establish when all those people took office.", "before": { "release": "v6", "positions": 0 }, "after": { "release": "v7", "positions": 75 }, "source_ids": [], "observation_ids": [], "gaps": [ "Not a historical change-of-office roster; prior service intervals still need source collection." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-org-mlgw-appointment", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Clarified: Appoints five Memphis commissioners", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed collection changed", "summary": "Memphia changed its reviewed chart evidence. This comparison does not establish the date government authority changed.", "before": { "id": "org-mlgw-appointment", "from": "city-mayor", "to": "mlgw-board", "label": "Appoints board members", "lane": "appointment", "status": "supported", "source_ids": [ "CITY08" ], "note": "Utility governance explanation; verify applicable instrument and dated appointment." }, "after": { "id": "org-mlgw-appointment", "from": "city-mayor", "to": "mlgw-board", "label": "Appoints five Memphis commissioners", "lane": "appointment", "status": "supported", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWGOV", "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION" ], "note": "This route is scoped to the five Memphis seats. July 2026 release describes two additional suburban voting seats with different selection routes; final Public Chapter 1116 text was not readable, and individual term instruments remain unqualified." }, "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWGOV", "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc", "obs-CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION-7b9ed7219298" ], "gaps": [ "Government event/effective dates require their own instruments." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-org-mlgw-confirmation", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Clarified: Confirms five Memphis appointments", "body_node_id": "mlgw-board", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed collection changed", "summary": "Memphia changed its reviewed chart evidence. This comparison does not establish the date government authority changed.", "before": { "id": "org-mlgw-confirmation", "from": "city-council", "to": "mlgw-board", "label": "Confirms board appointments", "lane": "appointment", "status": "supported", "source_ids": [ "CITY08" ], "note": "Confirmation is distinct from utility operation and does not prove responsibility for a particular outage." }, "after": { "id": "org-mlgw-confirmation", "from": "city-council", "to": "mlgw-board", "label": "Confirms five Memphis appointments", "lane": "appointment", "status": "supported", "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWGOV", "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION" ], "note": "Council confirmation scope is the five Memphis seats described by governance/transition sources. Do not extend this to the two suburban seats without final governing text and appointment instruments." }, "source_ids": [ "CITY7-MLGWGOV", "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc", "obs-CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION-7b9ed7219298" ], "gaps": [ "Government event/effective dates require their own instruments." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-org-lucb-city-mayor-appointments", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Added: Appoints five city LUCB members", "body_node_id": "lucb", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed collection changed", "summary": "Memphia changed its reviewed chart evidence. This comparison does not establish the date government authority changed.", "before": null, "after": { "id": "org-lucb-city-mayor-appointments", "to": "lucb", "label": "Appoints five city LUCB members", "lane": "appointment", "status": "supported", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "note": "Current joint-board directory describes this route and three-year term rule. Individual appointment/confirmation instruments and term endpoints are not collected.", "from": "city-mayor" }, "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Government event/effective dates require their own instruments." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-org-lucb-city-council-appointments", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Added: Confirms city LUCB appointments", "body_node_id": "lucb", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed collection changed", "summary": "Memphia changed its reviewed chart evidence. This comparison does not establish the date government authority changed.", "before": null, "after": { "id": "org-lucb-city-council-appointments", "to": "lucb", "label": "Confirms city LUCB appointments", "lane": "appointment", "status": "supported", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "note": "Current joint-board directory describes this route and three-year term rule. Individual appointment/confirmation instruments and term endpoints are not collected.", "from": "city-council" }, "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Government event/effective dates require their own instruments." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-org-lucb-county-mayor-appointments", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Added: Appoints five county LUCB members", "body_node_id": "lucb", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed collection changed", "summary": "Memphia changed its reviewed chart evidence. This comparison does not establish the date government authority changed.", "before": null, "after": { "id": "org-lucb-county-mayor-appointments", "to": "lucb", "label": "Appoints five county LUCB members", "lane": "appointment", "status": "supported", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "note": "Current joint-board directory describes this route and three-year term rule. Individual appointment/confirmation instruments and term endpoints are not collected.", "from": "county-mayor" }, "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Government event/effective dates require their own instruments." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-org-lucb-county-commission-appointments", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Added: Confirms county LUCB appointments", "body_node_id": "lucb", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T05:40:59.280448+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed collection changed", "summary": "Memphia changed its reviewed chart evidence. This comparison does not establish the date government authority changed.", "before": null, "after": { "id": "org-lucb-county-commission-appointments", "to": "lucb", "label": "Confirms county LUCB appointments", "lane": "appointment", "status": "supported", "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "note": "Current joint-board directory describes this route and three-year term rule. Individual appointment/confirmation instruments and term endpoints are not collected.", "from": "county-commission" }, "source_ids": [ "ROOT7-LUCB" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROOT7-LUCB-fc9fb0d580d0" ], "gaps": [ "Government event/effective dates require their own instruments." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-v8-role-context-and-framing", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Added responsibility context and corrected portrait framing", "body_node_id": null, "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:20:15.156336+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed presentation changed", "summary": "Person cards now explain their role,limits,related issues and selected recorded actions. All49government portraits reviewed;18display crops adjusted,including the off-center Memphis mayor image. Utility appointment wording in the issue subgraph is reconciled with the qualified organization chart.", "baseline_revision": "ST096-local-v7", "before": { "revision": "v7", "role_contexts": 0, "portrait_framing": "Default centered crop" }, "after": { "revision": "v8", "body_contexts": 23, "position_exceptions": 25, "portraits_reviewed": 49, "portraits_adjusted": 18 }, "source_ids": [ "CITY01", "CITY02", "CITY03", "CITY7-MAYOR", "CITY7-MLGWGOV", "CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-CITY01-be604a8afc83", "obs-CITY02-1eab8766c07b", "obs-CITY03-385688d37291", "obs-CITY7-MAYOR-9b22872db8f2", "obs-CITY7-MLGWGOV-0e51b3e8eedc", "obs-CITY7-MLGWTRANSITION-7b9ed7219298" ], "gaps": [ "Role context reuses dated qualified evidence; complete operative law and individual delegations remain unresolved where labelled.", "Presentation review does not establish a new government action,effective policy date or new source portrait." ], "supersedes": [], "corrects": [] }, { "id": "collection-correction-v8-resolved-photo-access-notes", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Resolved portrait-access notes and retained source conflicts", "body_node_id": null, "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:22:13.129063+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Collection annotation corrected", "baseline_revision": "ST096-local-v7", "summary": "Removed stale unresolved-image-URL wording from15position records that already have locally retained,sourced portraits. Broader reuse permissions remain qualified. Existing conflicting roster/leadership claims remain visible beside affected profiles.", "before": { "stale_portrait_access_notes": 15 }, "after": { "stale_portrait_access_notes": 0, "source_image_bytes_changed": false }, "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-BUCKNER-PROFILE", "COUNTY7-CHARTER", "COUNTY7-MAPS", "COUNTY7-MAYOR", "COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D1", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D11", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D12", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D13", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D2", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D5", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D6", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D7", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D8", "COUNTY7-PROFILE-D9", "COUNTY7-ROLE", "COUNTY7-ROSTER", "COUNTY7-SHERIFF", "COUNTY7-SHERIFF-STALE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-ROSTER-b4533ec01cdc", "obs-COUNTY7-MAYOR-6b7eb2a7ed51", "obs-COUNTY7-CHARTER-3d4c050b27db", "obs-COUNTY7-ROLE-530a38445da0", "obs-COUNTY7-MAPS-85afcb0f50ac", "obs-COUNTY7-MINUTES-SEP23-a35ba58e10c3", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D1-10a9d00cd290", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D2-992e7f50763e", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D5-d25389ecd457", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D6-9247fcc8ab4a", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D7-75eb6eb30ce5", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D8-53f375f5b45f", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D9-b607944d97dc", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D11-49eb980785fb", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D12-df09ea18fe84", "obs-COUNTY7-PROFILE-D13-64e118c86425", "obs-COUNTY7-SHERIFF-adeeb184c017", "obs-COUNTY7-SHERIFF-STALE-26489edb8573", "obs-COUNTY7-BUCKNER-PROFILE-fb2faba3d2f7" ], "gaps": [ "This corrects Memphia presentation metadata; it does not establish a government event,date or broader image reuse permission." ], "corrects": [ "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d1-person-rhonda-o-dell", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d2-person-derek-mills", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d3-person-michele-dial", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d4-person-mark-billingsley", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d5-person-shante-k-avant", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d6-person-charlie-a-caswell-jr", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d7-person-henri-e-brooks", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d8-person-will-richardson", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d9-person-dr-karen-streeter", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d10-person-lashanta-rudd", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d11-person-miska-clay-bibbs", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d12-person-dr-erika-sugarmon", "history-service-v7-county7-commission-d13-person-amber-huett-garcia", "history-service-v7-county7-mayor-pos-person-mickell-m-lowery", "history-service-v7-county7-sheriff-pos-person-anthony-j-buckner" ], "supersedes": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-v8-reviewed-governor-action-links", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Linked sourced gubernatorial appointments to the named actor", "body_node_id": "state-governor", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:23:48.110121+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed identity links added", "baseline_revision": "ST096-local-v7", "summary": "Three official appointment announcements identify Governor Bill Lee. Their person-position references now let his card surface those sampled actions. Each event retains its dated role; no current-mayor reference is added to historical Strickland appointments.", "before": { "governor_person_links": 0 }, "after": { "governor_person_links": 3 }, "source_ids": [ "COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS", "ROOT7-CABINET", "ROOT7-OVERSIGHT", "ROOT7-TDOT", "ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINT" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS-ee2dd4fa7df6", "obs-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-7b6fca01bb92", "obs-ROOT7-CABINET-63e7a01bc52b", "obs-ROOT7-TDOT-34a1cb3fd59a", "obs-ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINT-e315ec5f3750" ], "gaps": [ "This is curated record linkage,not a new appointment or policy-effective event." ], "corrects": [ "history-ROOT7-OVERSIGHT-APPOINTMENT-EVENT", "history-ROOT7-TDOT-APPOINTMENT-EVENT", "history-COUNTY7-JUDICIAL-APPOINTMENTS-EVENT" ], "supersedes": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-v9-issue-action-routes", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Connected roads and utilities to offices, official channels and questions", "body_node_id": null, "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T06:51:56.665229+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Reviewed routes added; authority gaps retained", "baseline_revision": "ST096-local-v8", "summary": "Added six lane routes using exact body/action IDs and six freshly captured official channel directories. Existing ten sampled actions remain unchanged. School powers remain conditional after a bounded access and public-docket recheck. This collection update is not a government action or effective-date claim.", "before": { "actionable_issue_routes": 0 }, "after": { "actionable_issue_routes": 2, "lanes": 6, "new_official_channel_observations": 6 }, "source_ids": [ "ROUTE9-CITY311", "ROUTE9-TDOT", "ROUTE9-MLGWCONTACT", "ROUTE9-MLGWMINUTES", "ROUTE9-COUNCIL", "ROUTE9-MLGWRECORDS" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-ROUTE9-CITY311-a6ed560f7894", "obs-ROUTE9-TDOT-79bf92514967", "obs-ROUTE9-MLGWCONTACT-320401e2bbc6", "obs-ROUTE9-MLGWMINUTES-47c57a1ea281", "obs-ROUTE9-COUNCIL-fbb634742822", "obs-ROUTE9-MLGWRECORDS-a4e08e541a43" ], "gaps": [ "No resident usefulness trial yet.", "School final statute and operative orders remain unqualified.", "No relevant adopted road repair or utility rate/project decision has been collected for these lanes." ], "corrects": [], "supersedes": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-v10-school-document-qualification", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Qualified final school law and traced orders versus declaration", "body_node_id": "mscs-oversight", "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Final-text gap closed; court coverage and procedure gaps retained", "baseline_revision": "ST096-local-v9", "summary": "Added final-act, court/order/filing and channel observations, four school action routes, final-law context and a distinct federal court node. Current exclusive authority is not asserted. Old evidence and unknown dates remain attributable.", "before": { "final_act_read": false, "school_action_routes": 0, "federal_court_node": false }, "after": { "final_act_read": true, "school_action_routes": 4, "federal_court_node": true, "public_docket_known_through": "2026-10-13" }, "source_ids": [ "SCHOOL10-ACT", "SCHOOL10-BILL", "COURT10-OCT5", "COURT10-DECL82", "COURT10-EXH-A", "COURT10-EXH-B", "COURT10-EXH-C", "COURT10-EXH-D", "COURT10-JULY1", "COURT10-DOCKET", "SCHOOL10-BOARDCHANNEL", "SCHOOL10-PARTICIPATION", "SCHOOL10-NOTICE" ], "observation_ids": [ "obs-SCHOOL10-ACT-fa72578887ac", "obs-SCHOOL10-BILL-116e3844db37", "obs-COURT10-OCT5-8c5e5abcdf65", "obs-COURT10-DECL82-fa25d797690b", "obs-COURT10-EXH-A-7d1ac25e7867", "obs-COURT10-EXH-B-7d1ac25e7867", "obs-COURT10-EXH-C-7d1ac25e7867", "obs-COURT10-EXH-D-7d1ac25e7867", "obs-COURT10-JULY1-1f5cf7933183", "obs-COURT10-DOCKET-8abbbb9641aa", "obs-SCHOOL10-BOARDCHANNEL-9d71d0bfa207", "obs-SCHOOL10-PARTICIPATION-e4d222f76d30", "obs-SCHOOL10-NOTICE-a57d99d058fd" ], "gaps": [ "The July 1 order requires the pre-act status quo; the October 5 order holds the dissolution request in abeyance. The October 13 chair declaration states readiness, but is not a lifting order. The public docket is known through October 13; a later official ruling remains unqualified.", "The filed procedures contain blank adoption/certification, address and schedule fields. Exact October 8 motions/votes and later signed amendments remain unreviewed. Follow current dated notices; public-comment timing differs between the October 8 notice and filed rules." ], "corrects": [ "history-policy-school1057" ], "supersedes": [] }, { "id": "collection-change-v10-government-chart-layout", "kind": "collection_change", "title": "Separated government sections and restored supervised private reader", "body_node_id": null, "observed_on": "2026-10-14", "recorded_at": "2026-10-14T13:54:40.948242+00:00", "event_date": null, "effective_date": null, "status": "Private presentation/runtime update", "baseline_revision": "ST096-local-v9", "summary": "Stacked Memphis, Shelby County, shared bodies, Tennessee and federal judicial context. Named source-bound relationship records replace crossing lines; underlying body scopes remain intact. Restored Tailscale backend and added dedicated automatic restart/login startup. This is a collection/service change, not a government reorganization.", "before": { "city_county_layout": "side_by_side", "tailnet_response": 502 }, "after": { "city_county_layout": "stacked", "tailnet_response": 200, "backend_supervision": "dedicated_launchagent" }, "source_ids": [], "observation_ids": [], "gaps": [ "Same-host software/endpoint checks do not establish other-device availability or resident comprehension.", "Host must remain awake and connected to Tailscale." ], "corrects": [], "supersedes": [] } ], "limits": [ "This is the first frozen observation/event collection; previous complete officeholder histories were not reconstructed.", "Observed/recorded time is separate from event, service and policy-effective time.", "Unknown dates stay null. Corrections must append linked records; prior evidence remains in versioned snapshots.", "Retained byte/DOM captures are identified separately from link-only reviewed notes. A hash does not validate legal applicability." ] }